The Literature Review in Qualitative Research
❦
The Role of the Review
A qualitative literature review shows what is known, identifies the gap, develops the concepts and theories that sensitize you to the topic, and justifies your design. Unlike in hypothesis-testing research, it should inform without constraining your analysis, so that you remain open to what participants say (Ridley, 2012; Booth et al., 2016). In grounded theory, there is a debate about when to read the literature: Glaser (1978) advised delaying the main review until the analysis is under way, while Charmaz (2014) and Corbin and Strauss (2015) accept an early review used with care. Follow your supervisor's guidance and your university's requirements, which usually require a review in the proposal.
Searching Systematically
- Define concepts and list synonyms.
- Databases: use your library's resources such as Scopus, Web of Science, ProQuest, EBSCO, JSTOR, SAGE, Taylor & Francis, Emerald, ScienceDirect, PubMed or CINAHL for health, ERIC for education, PsycINFO for psychology, and Google Scholar as a supplement. In Sri Lanka, Sri Lanka Journals Online (SLJOL) hosts many national journals.
- Search strings: combine terms with AND, OR, and NOT; use quotation marks and truncation. Include method terms such as "qualitative", "interview", "case study", or "thematic analysis" to find qualitative studies.
- Citation chasing: follow references backward and citations forward.
- Record searches, and use a reference manager (Zotero, Mendeley, EndNote).
- Check quality: prefer peer-reviewed journals, check journal rankings where relevant, and avoid predatory outlets ("Think. Check. Submit.").
Appraising Qualitative Studies
The Critical Appraisal Skills Programme (CASP) provides a checklist for qualitative research that asks, among other things, whether the aims and methodology were clear and appropriate, whether recruitment and data collection were suitable, whether the researcher's role was considered, whether ethics were addressed, whether the analysis was rigorous, and how valuable the research is (CASP, n.d.). Use such tools to judge sources.
Types of Review
| Type | Use |
|---|---|
| Narrative or critical review | Most dissertations; organized by theme and argument |
| Conceptual or theoretical review | Compares definitions and theories; builds a framework |
| Scoping review | Maps the extent of a field |
| Systematic review | Answers a focused question using explicit, reproducible methods and a flow diagram (Page et al., 2021) |
| Qualitative evidence synthesis | Integrates findings of qualitative studies, for example meta-ethnography (Noblit & Hare, 1988) or thematic synthesis (Thomas & Harden, 2008) |
Structuring the Chapter
1. Introduction and the logic of organization.
2. Key concepts and definitions of the central phenomenon.
3. Theoretical perspectives relevant to the topic.
4. Empirical studies, grouped by theme, comparing methods and findings, with attention to qualitative evidence and to the context.
5. The research gap, stated clearly.
6. A summary leading to the conceptual framework (Chapter 7) and the research questions.
Reading and Writing Critically
For each source note the question, context, participants, method, findings, strengths, and limits. Use a synthesis matrix (sources in rows; themes in columns). Write by theme, compare and contrast, explain disagreements, and use your own voice. Avoid "Author A said X. Author B said Y."
Common Mistakes
- Using only older or non-peer-reviewed sources.
- Reviewing only quantitative studies when qualitative evidence exists.
- Not linking the review to the gap and the question.
- Copying or closely paraphrasing text.
- Letting the review determine your codes so rigidly that you ignore the data.
CHAPTER 7