Theoretical and Conceptual Frameworks in Qualitative Research
❦
Terms
- A theory explains a phenomenon.
- A theoretical framework is the theory or theories that inform your study.
- A conceptual framework is the system of concepts, assumptions, expectations, beliefs, and theories that supports and informs your research (Maxwell, 2013; Miles et al., 2020). It may be shown as a diagram and an explanatory narrative.
- A sensitizing concept gives a general sense of where to look without prescribing what to see (Blumer, 1954).
Ravitch and Riggan (2017) argue that a conceptual framework should link the topic, literature, theory, and your own experience and methods, and so provide a rationale and a guide to the research.
How Theory Is Used in Qualitative Research
| Use | Description |
|---|---|
| As a lens | A theory (for example feminist theory, institutional theory) shapes the questions and interpretation |
| As a sensitizing device | Concepts guide the initial focus but do not limit analysis |
| As a testable proposition set | In post-positivist case studies, propositions are compared with data (Yin, 2018) |
| As a product | In grounded theory, theory is built from the data |
| As a late-stage resource | Theory is brought in after open coding to deepen interpretation |
Use theory in a way that fits your methodology. Do not force the data into a theory or ignore data that do not fit.
Examples of Frameworks Used Across Fields
| Field | Theories and frameworks | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Business | Institutional theory; resource-based view; stakeholder theory; sensemaking; the technology-organization-environment framework | DiMaggio and Powell (1983); Barney (1991); Freeman (1984); Tornatzky and Fleischer (1990) |
| Education | Communities of practice; constructivist learning; critical pedagogy | Lave and Wenger (1991) |
| Health | The social ecological model; the health belief model; patient-centred care | Bronfenbrenner (1979) |
| Psychology | Attachment, identity, and narrative theories | Various |
| Sociology | Symbolic interactionism, structuration, intersectionality | Blumer (1954) |
| Information systems | Technology acceptance and adoption models; sociomaterial perspectives | Davis (1989) |
Building a Conceptual Framework: Steps
1. List the key concepts from your topic and questions.
2. Review the literature and theory to define them and find relationships.
3. Add your own experience and assumptions (reflexivity).
4. Draw a diagram showing the concepts and the relationships you expect to explore, using boxes and arrows as provisional connections, not hypotheses.
5. Write a narrative explaining each element and how it informs the questions and the data collection (for example, which concepts shape the interview guide).
6. Stay open: revise the framework as the study develops, and report how it changed.
A simple example (text diagram)
| Context | Process | Outcomes |
|---|---|---|
| Regulatory environment, infrastructure, social norms | Owner's evaluation of digital payments; support from peers and family; trial and adaptation | Changes in practice; perceived benefits and difficulties |
| (Framework concepts: institutional pressures, sensemaking, and the technology-organization-environment framework) |
Frameworks in Different Traditions
- Grounded theory often begins with a minimal framework and builds the theory from data.
- Phenomenology brackets or reflects on prior assumptions (the stance depends on the tradition).
- Case study often uses a framework or propositions to focus data collection.
- Critical and participatory studies use a theory of power or social change.
Common Mistakes
- Adopting a theory because it is popular rather than because it fits.
- Treating the framework as a set of hypotheses to be confirmed.
- Not explaining how the framework shaped the design.
- Failing to revisit the framework in the discussion.
CHAPTER 8