Prof. Dr. Larry AdamsAcademic, Author & Researcher
Qualitative Research · Chapter 5 of 26

Choosing a Topic and Framing Qualitative Research Questions

❦

Where Topics Come From

Topics come from your discipline's debates, from practice and professional experience, from gaps identified in recent literature ("future research" sections), from social and policy issues, and from your supervisor's interests. For a topic to work in a qualitative study, it should concern meaning, experience, process, or context that can be explored through participants' accounts or documents.

From Interest to a Researchable Topic

StepExample (business)Example (health)
Broad areaDigital transformationChronic illness
TopicDigital payments among small enterprisesSelf-management of diabetes
Problem or gapLittle is known about how micro-entrepreneurs in regional areas experience adoptionPatients' day-to-day decision-making is poorly understood in low-resource settings
Focused questionHow do women micro-entrepreneurs in a regional district experience and make decisions about adopting digital payments?How do adults with type 2 diabetes make everyday decisions about diet and medication?

Criteria for a Good Qualitative Topic

CriterionCheck
SignificanceDoes it matter for theory, practice, or policy?
ResearchableCan participants or documents provide data?
FeasibleTime, skills, access, and resources
Original contributionNew context, population, process, or perspective
EthicalCan it be done without undue harm?
FitDoes it suit a qualitative approach, and does your supervisor have expertise?
InterestWill you stay committed over months?

Types of Gaps

Contextual (a new country or sector), population (an unstudied group), theoretical (theory not applied here), methodological (only surveys so far; no in-depth understanding), empirical (conflicting findings), and temporal (changed conditions).

Writing Qualitative Research Questions

A qualitative research question is open-ended, focused, and about meaning, process, or experience. It typically starts with how or what (avoid why as a main question when it implies simple cause), uses exploratory verbs such as explore, understand, describe, interpret, discover, names the central phenomenon, the participants, and the setting, and avoids terms of prediction or measurement (Creswell & Poth, 2018; Maxwell, 2013).

WeakStronger
Does leadership style affect employee performance? (a variable question; better suited to a survey)How do front-line employees experience and interpret their managers' leadership during organizational restructuring?
Why do students drop out? (too broad; implies a single cause)How do first-year students describe their decisions to continue or withdraw from their programme?
Is the policy effective? (evaluative yes/no)How do officials interpret and implement the policy in their daily work?

Central question and sub-questions: a central question captures the main inquiry, and sub-questions divide it into manageable parts (about three to five). Keep the number small.

Purpose Statement Template

"The purpose of this qualitative [tradition] study is to [explore/understand/describe] [the central phenomenon] among [participants] in [setting]. At this stage in the research, [the phenomenon] will be generally defined as [definition]."

Aims, Objectives, and Hypotheses

Use aims (the broad purpose) and objectives (specific actions: to explore, to identify, to examine, to interpret). Qualitative studies do not usually state statistical hypotheses; instead they may state propositions (in case studies) or sensitizing questions. Check whether your university requires hypotheses and, if so, how to word qualitative alternatives.

Significance and Scope

State the significance (for theory, practice, and policy), the scope (participants, setting, period), and the delimitations (what you have chosen not to study). Define key terms provisionally, and refine them as the analysis proceeds.

Maxwell's Interactive Model

Maxwell (2013) suggests that qualitative design is interactive, with five components that must fit together: goals, conceptual framework, research questions, methods, and validity. Check alignment between each pair.

QuestionGoal it servesData neededMethodAnalysis
RQ1: How do women micro-entrepreneurs experience the adoption of digital payments?To understand experienceAccounts of adoptionSemi-structured interviewsReflexive thematic analysis
RQ2: What shapes their decisions?To identify influencesAccounts and observationsInterviews and field notesThematic analysis and cross-case comparison
RQ3: How do they adapt practices after adoption?To understand changeAccounts and recordsInterviews and documentsProcess coding

CHAPTER 6