Understanding University Research Standards and Requirements
❦
The Hierarchy of Rules
Your research is governed by several layers of rules. When they conflict, follow the more specific, and always confirm with your supervisor and programme coordinator.
| Layer | Examples |
|---|---|
| National and international | National qualifications frameworks; quality assurance agencies; data protection and copyright laws |
| University | Degree regulations; research ethics policy; plagiarism and AI policy; thesis deposit rules |
| Faculty or school | Dissertation guidelines, templates, marking schemes |
| Department or programme | Research methods course; topic lists; supervisor allocation; seminars |
| Supervisor and committee | Expectations for drafts, meetings, and methods |
| Journal or funder (for publication or grants) | Author guidelines; reporting standards |
In Sri Lanka, for example, the Sri Lanka Qualifications Framework (SLQF) prepared by the University Grants Commission describes the levels and the volume of learning for each qualification. Honours degrees include a research component, master's degrees with a research component require a research project of at least 15 credits within 60 credits, an MPhil requires at least two years of research, and a PhD requires at least three years (UGC, 2016; University of Kelaniya, 2023). Other countries have comparable frameworks (for example, qualifications frameworks in the United Kingdom, Europe, Australia, and Malaysia). Always consult the version used by your institution.
Typical Requirements for a Qualitative Thesis or Dissertation
| Element | Typical practice | What to confirm |
|---|---|---|
| Proposal | Approved before fieldwork; often a few pages for undergraduates and a fuller document for postgraduates | Length, headings, approval body, deadlines |
| Title | A concise, informative title, sometimes with a word limit | Word limit and wording rules |
| Questions and aims | A central question with sub-questions, and aims or objectives; qualitative studies usually do not state statistical hypotheses | Number of objectives allowed |
| Philosophy and methodology | An explicit statement of paradigm, tradition, and justification | Whether a philosophy section is required |
| Sampling | A purposive sample justified by the aims; explanation of how saturation or information power was judged | Expected sample sizes for your level and field |
| Ethics | Clearance from an ethics committee and written permissions from organizations | The committee, forms, and time required |
| Supervision | One or two supervisors; regular meetings; the supervisor advises but does not write the work | Meeting frequency and sign-off rules |
| Quality criteria | Trustworthiness, reflexivity, an audit trail | The examiners' expectations |
| Plagiarism and AI | A similarity check and a declaration; rules on disclosing the use of AI tools | The permitted similarity level and AI policy |
| Format | A prescribed referencing style (most often APA, Harvard, or Chicago), margins, font, spacing, and numbering | The official template |
| Length | Word or page limits that vary by level and field | What is included in the count |
| Assessment | Written work, supervisor's assessment, and often an oral examination (viva voce) | Weights and examiners |
| Submission | Hard-bound or electronic copies; deposit in a repository | Deadlines and copies |
Standards Differ by Field
| Field | Common expectations |
|---|---|
| Business and administration | A clear managerial or theoretical contribution; justification of the case or sample; often case study, interview-based, or grounded theory designs; the Gioia and Eisenhardt approaches are widely used (Eisenhardt, 1989; Gioia et al., 2013; Pratt, 2009; Easterby-Smith et al., 2021) |
| Education | Attention to context, participants' voices, and implications for practice |
| Health and nursing | Use of reporting checklists such as COREQ or SRQR; strict ethical review; patient and public involvement (Tong et al., 2007; O'Brien et al., 2014) |
| Psychology | Epistemological coherence and reflexivity; JARS-Qual reporting standards (Levitt et al., 2018) |
| Social sciences and anthropology | Theoretical engagement and thick description |
| Humanities and law | Interpretive argument; use of primary texts and archives |
| Information systems and engineering | Rigor frameworks such as case study protocols; interpretive field studies |
How to Find Your Own Standards
1. Obtain the current dissertation guidelines, template, and marking scheme from your programme coordinator.
2. Read the student handbook and degree regulations.
3. Learn the ethics process, forms, and timelines.
4. Check the plagiarism and AI policies and the permitted similarity index.
5. Read successful past dissertations, especially qualitative ones, noting structure, length, and style.
6. Ask your supervisor which qualitative traditions and methods are accepted in your department.
7. Record deadlines, copies, and viva arrangements.
8. Keep copies of all approvals.
Quality Criteria Examiners Commonly Apply
| Criterion | Examiners' questions |
|---|---|
| Relevance and contribution | Is the topic important? What does it add? |
| Coherence | Do the question, philosophy, design, analysis, and conclusions fit? |
| Literature and theory | Is the review critical and current? Is there a conceptual foundation? |
| Method | Is the design appropriate, justified, and described in enough detail to follow? |
| Rigor | Are credibility, transferability, dependability, and confirmability addressed? |
| Reflexivity | Does the researcher acknowledge their position and influence? |
| Analysis | Is it systematic, deep, and clearly linked to the data? |
| Interpretation | Are claims supported by the evidence, and are alternatives considered? |
| Ethics | Were participants protected? |
| Writing | Is it clear, well organized, properly referenced, and free of plagiarism? |
| Viva | Can the student explain and defend choices? |
CHAPTER 5