Prof. Dr. Larry AdamsAcademic, Author & Researcher
Qualitative Research · Chapter 3 of 26

Types and Traditions of Qualitative Research

❦

Types of Research in General

Before turning to qualitative traditions, note that research can be classified in several overlapping ways (Saunders et al., 2019; Bryman & Bell, 2015; Creswell & Creswell, 2023):

ClassificationTypes
By purposeBasic (theoretical) and applied; exploratory, descriptive, explanatory, evaluative, action-oriented
By approach to theoryDeductive, inductive, abductive
By methodological choiceQuantitative, qualitative, mixed methods, multimethod
By time horizonCross-sectional and longitudinal (including qualitative longitudinal research)
By data sourcePrimary and secondary (documents, archives, existing datasets)
By strategySurvey, experiment, case study, ethnography, grounded theory, action research, narrative inquiry, archival research

Qualitative research is usually inductive or abductive, exploratory, descriptive, or explanatory, and uses primary data (interviews, observation) or secondary qualitative data (documents, existing transcripts).

The Main Qualitative Traditions

TraditionCentral questionTypical dataKey sources
EthnographyHow does this group or culture work from the inside?Prolonged observation, field notes, interviews, artifactsHammersley & Atkinson (2019); Spradley (1980)
PhenomenologyWhat is the lived experience and its essence or meaning?In-depth interviewsGiorgi (2009); van Manen (2016); Smith et al. (2009)
Grounded theoryWhat theory explains this process?Interviews, observation, documents; constant comparisonGlaser and Strauss (1967); Corbin and Strauss (2015); Charmaz (2014)
Case studyHow does this bounded case work in its context?Multiple sources: interviews, documents, observationYin (2018); Stake (1995); Eisenhardt (1989)
Narrative inquiryWhat stories do people tell, and what do they mean?Life stories, interviews, diariesClandinin and Connelly (2000); Riessman (2008)
Qualitative content analysisWhat categories and meanings are in the texts?Documents, media, open-ended responsesHsieh and Shannon (2005); Mayring (2014); Krippendorff (2018)
Thematic analysis familyWhat patterns of meaning run across the data?Any textual dataBraun and Clarke (2006, 2021)
Framework analysisHow can data be systematically compared across cases and themes (common in applied policy research)?Interviews, focus groupsRitchie and Spencer (1994); Gale et al. (2013)
Discourse and conversation analysisHow do language and talk construct meaning and action?Talk, textsPotter and Wetherell (1987); Fairclough (1995); Sacks et al. (1974)
Action and participatory researchHow can we change practice with participants?Mixed; cycles of action and reflectionReason and Bradbury (2008); Stringer (2014)
AutoethnographyHow does personal experience illuminate cultural issues?The researcher's reflections and field notesEllis et al. (2011)
Netnography and digital researchHow do online communities and platforms shape practice?Posts, forums, social mediaKozinets (2015)
Document and archival researchWhat do documents reveal?Policies, reports, archivesBowen (2009)
Visual and arts-based methodsWhat do images and creative forms show?Photographs, drawings, videoPink (2013)
Qualitative evidence synthesisWhat do qualitative studies together tell us?Published qualitative studiesNoblit and Hare (1988); Thomas and Harden (2008)
Delphi and consensus methodsWhat do experts agree on?Rounds of expert inputUsed for frameworks and forecasting

How Traditions Differ in Practice

FeaturePhenomenologyGrounded theoryEthnographyCase study
AimEssence of experienceA theory of a processCultural descriptionIn-depth understanding of the case
SampleFew participants who share the experienceTheoretical sampling until categories are saturatedA site or groupOne to several cases
AnalysisMeaning units, themes, essence (or interpretive themes in IPA)Open, axial, and selective (or initial, focused, theoretical) codingThick description and patternsPattern matching, explanation building, cross-case synthesis
ProductA rich description of the experienceA substantive theory or modelAn ethnographic accountA case description and analytic propositions

Choosing a Tradition

If your question asks...Consider
What is it like to experience X?Phenomenology (IPA)
How does process Y unfold, and what explains it?Grounded theory or process case study
How does this community or workplace operate?Ethnography
How and why did this organization or programme work?Case study
How do people make sense of their lives through stories?Narrative inquiry
What patterns of meaning are in this dataset?Reflexive thematic analysis
What is in these documents or media?Content or document analysis
How can we improve this practice with those involved?Action research

Qualitative Research Across Fields

FieldTypical qualitative questions
Business and administrationHow do managers make strategic decisions? How do employees experience organizational change? How do micro-entrepreneurs adopt new technology?
EducationHow do students experience online learning? How do teachers interpret a new curriculum?
Health and nursingWhat is the experience of living with a chronic condition? How do patients navigate care?
PsychologyHow do people make sense of grief or identity?
Sociology and anthropologyHow do communities negotiate migration, class, or gender?
Information systems and technologyHow do users appropriate a new system? Why do projects fail?
Law and policyHow do officials implement a regulation?
Environment and developmentHow do communities perceive and adapt to climate change?
Humanities and mediaHow do texts, images, and audiences make meaning?

CHAPTER 4