Types and Traditions of Qualitative Research
❦
Types of Research in General
Before turning to qualitative traditions, note that research can be classified in several overlapping ways (Saunders et al., 2019; Bryman & Bell, 2015; Creswell & Creswell, 2023):
| Classification | Types |
|---|---|
| By purpose | Basic (theoretical) and applied; exploratory, descriptive, explanatory, evaluative, action-oriented |
| By approach to theory | Deductive, inductive, abductive |
| By methodological choice | Quantitative, qualitative, mixed methods, multimethod |
| By time horizon | Cross-sectional and longitudinal (including qualitative longitudinal research) |
| By data source | Primary and secondary (documents, archives, existing datasets) |
| By strategy | Survey, experiment, case study, ethnography, grounded theory, action research, narrative inquiry, archival research |
Qualitative research is usually inductive or abductive, exploratory, descriptive, or explanatory, and uses primary data (interviews, observation) or secondary qualitative data (documents, existing transcripts).
The Main Qualitative Traditions
| Tradition | Central question | Typical data | Key sources |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ethnography | How does this group or culture work from the inside? | Prolonged observation, field notes, interviews, artifacts | Hammersley & Atkinson (2019); Spradley (1980) |
| Phenomenology | What is the lived experience and its essence or meaning? | In-depth interviews | Giorgi (2009); van Manen (2016); Smith et al. (2009) |
| Grounded theory | What theory explains this process? | Interviews, observation, documents; constant comparison | Glaser and Strauss (1967); Corbin and Strauss (2015); Charmaz (2014) |
| Case study | How does this bounded case work in its context? | Multiple sources: interviews, documents, observation | Yin (2018); Stake (1995); Eisenhardt (1989) |
| Narrative inquiry | What stories do people tell, and what do they mean? | Life stories, interviews, diaries | Clandinin and Connelly (2000); Riessman (2008) |
| Qualitative content analysis | What categories and meanings are in the texts? | Documents, media, open-ended responses | Hsieh and Shannon (2005); Mayring (2014); Krippendorff (2018) |
| Thematic analysis family | What patterns of meaning run across the data? | Any textual data | Braun and Clarke (2006, 2021) |
| Framework analysis | How can data be systematically compared across cases and themes (common in applied policy research)? | Interviews, focus groups | Ritchie and Spencer (1994); Gale et al. (2013) |
| Discourse and conversation analysis | How do language and talk construct meaning and action? | Talk, texts | Potter and Wetherell (1987); Fairclough (1995); Sacks et al. (1974) |
| Action and participatory research | How can we change practice with participants? | Mixed; cycles of action and reflection | Reason and Bradbury (2008); Stringer (2014) |
| Autoethnography | How does personal experience illuminate cultural issues? | The researcher's reflections and field notes | Ellis et al. (2011) |
| Netnography and digital research | How do online communities and platforms shape practice? | Posts, forums, social media | Kozinets (2015) |
| Document and archival research | What do documents reveal? | Policies, reports, archives | Bowen (2009) |
| Visual and arts-based methods | What do images and creative forms show? | Photographs, drawings, video | Pink (2013) |
| Qualitative evidence synthesis | What do qualitative studies together tell us? | Published qualitative studies | Noblit and Hare (1988); Thomas and Harden (2008) |
| Delphi and consensus methods | What do experts agree on? | Rounds of expert input | Used for frameworks and forecasting |
How Traditions Differ in Practice
| Feature | Phenomenology | Grounded theory | Ethnography | Case study |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aim | Essence of experience | A theory of a process | Cultural description | In-depth understanding of the case |
| Sample | Few participants who share the experience | Theoretical sampling until categories are saturated | A site or group | One to several cases |
| Analysis | Meaning units, themes, essence (or interpretive themes in IPA) | Open, axial, and selective (or initial, focused, theoretical) coding | Thick description and patterns | Pattern matching, explanation building, cross-case synthesis |
| Product | A rich description of the experience | A substantive theory or model | An ethnographic account | A case description and analytic propositions |
Choosing a Tradition
| If your question asks... | Consider |
|---|---|
| What is it like to experience X? | Phenomenology (IPA) |
| How does process Y unfold, and what explains it? | Grounded theory or process case study |
| How does this community or workplace operate? | Ethnography |
| How and why did this organization or programme work? | Case study |
| How do people make sense of their lives through stories? | Narrative inquiry |
| What patterns of meaning are in this dataset? | Reflexive thematic analysis |
| What is in these documents or media? | Content or document analysis |
| How can we improve this practice with those involved? | Action research |
Qualitative Research Across Fields
| Field | Typical qualitative questions |
|---|---|
| Business and administration | How do managers make strategic decisions? How do employees experience organizational change? How do micro-entrepreneurs adopt new technology? |
| Education | How do students experience online learning? How do teachers interpret a new curriculum? |
| Health and nursing | What is the experience of living with a chronic condition? How do patients navigate care? |
| Psychology | How do people make sense of grief or identity? |
| Sociology and anthropology | How do communities negotiate migration, class, or gender? |
| Information systems and technology | How do users appropriate a new system? Why do projects fail? |
| Law and policy | How do officials implement a regulation? |
| Environment and development | How do communities perceive and adapt to climate change? |
| Humanities and media | How do texts, images, and audiences make meaning? |
CHAPTER 4