Philosophical Foundations: Paradigms and the Researcher's Stance
❦
Every research design rests on assumptions about the world and about knowledge. Making these explicit is a standard expectation in qualitative theses, and it ensures that your question, methods, and claims fit together (Crotty, 1998; Guba & Lincoln, 1994).
Four Layers of a Research Design
Crotty (1998) distinguishes four elements:
| Layer | Question | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Epistemology | What counts as knowledge? | Constructionism: knowledge is constructed in interaction |
| Theoretical perspective | What philosophical stance informs the methodology? | Interpretivism, critical inquiry, feminism |
| Methodology | What strategy links the choice of methods to the desired outcomes? | Grounded theory, case study, phenomenology |
| Methods | What techniques are used to gather and analyze data? | Interviews, observation, thematic analysis |
Key Terms
- Ontology: assumptions about the nature of reality (is there one reality, or multiple constructed realities?).
- Epistemology: assumptions about how we can know that reality and what the relationship between researcher and participant is.
- Axiology: the role of values in research.
- Methodology and methods: the overall logic versus the specific tools.
Main Paradigms
| Paradigm | Core assumptions | Typical qualitative approach |
|---|---|---|
| Post-positivism | A real world exists but is known imperfectly; seeks to reduce bias | Case study (Yin), content analysis, framework analysis |
| Interpretivism and constructivism | Realities are socially constructed; meaning is created in context | Phenomenology, ethnography, constructivist grounded theory, reflexive thematic analysis |
| Critical theory and transformative paradigms | Research should expose and challenge power and inequality | Critical ethnography, participatory action research, critical discourse analysis |
| Feminist, postcolonial, and Indigenous perspectives | Attention to gender, colonial histories, and local knowledge systems | Participatory and decolonizing methodologies |
| Pragmatism | Choose methods that best answer the question | Mixed methods; applied studies |
| Critical realism | A real world exists, with underlying mechanisms that are known through our interpretations | Case study, explanatory qualitative research |
| Post-structuralism and postmodernism | Knowledge is discursive and contingent | Discourse analysis, deconstruction |
Researcher Position and Reflexivity
In qualitative research, the researcher is the instrument. Your background, identity, experience, and assumptions shape what you ask, what you notice, and how you interpret. Reflexivity means examining this influence critically and openly, and it is a core quality criterion (Braun & Clarke, 2021; Tracy, 2010). A positionality statement says who you are in relation to the topic and participants (for example, an insider employee researching your own organization, or an outsider studying another community) and how this may affect the research.
| Position | Advantages | Cautions |
|---|---|---|
| Insider | Access, trust, shared language | Taking things for granted; role conflict; bias; confidentiality |
| Outsider | Fresh perspective; analytic distance | Access; misunderstanding context; trust |
| In-between | Combines both | Needs reflexive attention |
Why Philosophy Matters in Practice
A coherent design aligns the paradigm with the question and the method. For example, a constructivist study of how employees experience restructuring would use interviews and an interpretive analysis, and would not claim to measure the "true" level of stress; a post-positivist case study might use multiple sources and a pre-specified coding framework to test a proposition. Examiners often ask, "Why this approach?" and "How is your analysis consistent with your assumptions?"
CHAPTER 3