3. Identifying and Appraising Research Problems
3.1 What makes a research problem?
A research problem is a clearly expressed issue, uncertainty, contradiction, unmet need, or evidence gap that warrants systematic investigation. It may arise from practice, policy, theory, published research, stakeholder concerns, or a measurable change in outcomes. “Communication is poor” is a concern, not yet a researchable problem. A more focused formulation might be: “Project teams in a regional construction firm report repeated handover delays, but the organisation lacks evidence about whether role ambiguity, information-system usability, or approval procedures are most strongly associated with those delays.”
3.2 Sources of research problems
Useful starting points include workplace performance data, employee feedback, customer complaints, project post-mortems, audit reports, policy changes, published literature, and differences between expected and observed outcomes. Researchers should distinguish a symptom from a possible cause. A fall in customer satisfaction may be the symptom; long waiting times, unclear communication, inconsistent service, or changing customer expectations may be potential explanations. Early assumptions must be tested rather than presented as established facts.
3.3 Appraising a problem: clarity, focus, feasibility, relevance
The source presentation identifies four appraisal criteria: clarity, focus, feasibility, and relevance. Clarity means that the problem can be understood without ambiguous wording. Focus means the scope is sufficiently bounded. Feasibility means that the study can be completed with available time, access, skills, resources, and ethical permissions. Relevance means the question matters to scholarship, practice, policy, or affected communities. A socially important topic may still be unfeasible if the researcher cannot access the required data or protect participants.
3.4 Good versus poor problem statements
A poor problem statement is excessively broad, uses unexplained terms, assumes its conclusion, or cannot be investigated with available evidence. “How can technology solve poverty everywhere?” is too broad for a single postgraduate project. A stronger version specifies a setting, population, outcome, and period: “How do access to digital payment services and perceived transaction costs relate to the use of formal financial services among small retailers in one district?” The revised question is still open to findings that do not support the researcher’s expectations.
3.5 The socio-economic significance test
Ask who experiences the problem, how it affects resources or opportunities, what groups may be disproportionately affected, and what evidence could distinguish competing explanations. For example, low participation in professional training may reflect limited motivation, but it may also reflect shift patterns, unpaid care work, transport costs, language barriers, or limited internet access. Research should not individualise a structural problem without evidence. At the same time, structural explanations must also be investigated rather than assumed.
3.6 Scope, boundaries, and delimitations
A research project needs explicit boundaries: setting, population, time period, unit of analysis, concepts, and outcomes. Delimitations are boundaries intentionally selected by the researcher; limitations are constraints that may affect interpretation, such as low response rates or incomplete records. A study of one organisation can generate useful contextual knowledge but should not automatically claim to represent an entire industry or country.
3.7 Turning a concern into a researchable problem
A practical sequence is: describe the observed issue; establish why it matters; review what is already known; identify what remains uncertain; specify the setting and population; and state what evidence could help resolve the uncertainty. The researcher should also consider whether the proposed question is answerable through research or is primarily a request for a managerial decision. “Should we close the branch?” is a decision; researchable subquestions might concern service demand, operating costs, access impacts, and alternatives.