Prof. Dr. Larry AdamsAcademic, Author & Researcher
Research Methods — Level 7 · Chapter 3 of 20

2. Theories and Philosophical Foundations of Research

2.1 What theory contributes

A theory is a connected set of concepts and propositions used to explain, interpret, or predict phenomena. Theories help researchers decide what may matter, how variables or experiences might be connected, and what evidence could challenge an explanation. A theory is not simply a topic or a diagram. A conceptual framework may adapt ideas from several theories to represent the relationships relevant to one study. At Level 7, students should explain why a theory fits the problem, how it has been used in previous research, what assumptions it makes, and where its explanatory limits lie.

2.2 Positivism and post-positivism

Positivist approaches generally emphasise observable evidence, measurement, regularities, and systematic testing. They are often associated with structured instruments, hypotheses, and statistical analysis. Post-positivism recognises that observations and measures are imperfect, that researchers can be mistaken, and that conclusions should remain open to revision. For example, a study may test whether training hours are associated with employee performance, while acknowledging that performance also depends on task complexity, resources, management support, and measurement quality. Numerical analysis cannot automatically establish causation.

2.3 Interpretivism and social construction

Interpretivist approaches seek to understand how people interpret their experiences and construct meaning in particular settings. They are useful when the research question concerns trust, identity, organisational culture, perceived fairness, or the meaning employees attach to change. Interviews, observations, and documents may reveal that a policy formally described as flexible is experienced by some staff as autonomy and by others as constant availability. Interpretive research does not mean that any opinion is equally well supported: the researcher must show how interpretations are grounded in data and how alternative readings were considered.

2.4 Pragmatism and methodological choice

Pragmatism places emphasis on the research question and the practical consequences of inquiry. It can support the use of qualitative, quantitative, or mixed methods where each contributes useful evidence. A project investigating why a new scheduling system is unpopular might first use interviews to identify concerns, then a survey to estimate how widespread they are, and finally follow-up interviews to interpret unexpected results. The approach should not be selected merely because it sounds flexible; the researcher must explain why the combination is necessary and how the evidence will be integrated (Creswell & Creswell, 2023).

2.5 Deduction, induction, and abduction

Deduction starts with theory and derives propositions or hypotheses that can be tested against evidence. Induction begins with observations and develops patterns or concepts from the data. Abduction moves between evidence and possible explanations, asking which interpretation best accounts for an observed finding. In applied research, these logics may interact. A researcher could begin with a theory of organisational justice, notice an unexpected pattern in staff interviews, and return to the literature to assess whether a different mechanism better explains the evidence. The chosen logic should be consistent with the aim, design, and claims.

2.6 Critical realism and systems thinking

Critical realism distinguishes between observed events and the deeper mechanisms or structures that may generate them. This can be helpful for socio-economic questions because visible outcomes often emerge from multiple interacting causes. Systems thinking similarly encourages attention to feedback loops, dependencies, delays, and unintended consequences. For instance, increasing delivery targets may initially raise output but later increase fatigue, errors, absence, and staff turnover. A good study defines the system boundary and avoids claiming that one variable explains the entire system.

2.7 Choosing and defending a position

A research philosophy should be stated in practical terms. Explain the assumptions about what can be known, how knowledge will be developed, what counts as credible evidence, and how the approach shapes design decisions. Do not list several philosophies without showing their relevance. Nor should philosophy become decorative language: it must connect to sampling, data collection, analysis, reflexivity, and the strength of the final claims (Saunders et al., 2023).