Prof. Dr. Larry AdamsAcademic, Author & Researcher
Theological Philosophy Through a Biblical Perspective · Chapter 13 of 27

Part III — THE CHRISTIAN FATHERS AND THE CONFESSION OF CHRIST

9. The Early Church and the Rule of Faith

The earliest Christians inherited Israel’s Scriptures and proclaimed Jesus as the crucified and risen Lord. Their worship, baptismal practice, preaching, and teaching had to express both the oneness of God and the extraordinary identity of Christ. The New Testament itself contains early confessional summaries, such as 1 Corinthians 15:3–5, which Paul says he received and delivered: Christ died for our sins, was buried, rose again, and appeared to witnesses.

The phrase “rule of faith” refers to a summary of the church’s apostolic teaching used in instruction and interpretation. Early Christian writers employed such summaries to distinguish the public apostolic faith from interpretations that distorted the Scriptures. The rule of faith did not replace the biblical writings; it served as a concise guide to reading them within the church’s confession of the Creator, incarnation, death, resurrection, judgment, and hope.

Irenaeus of Lyons, writing in the second century, opposed teachings that fragmented the biblical story or separated the Creator from the God revealed in Christ. In Against Heresies, he emphasised the unity of God’s saving purpose and the reality of the incarnation. His arguments are historically important because they show that early Christians regarded the identity of Christ and the continuity of the Testaments as matters of central concern.

Ignatius of Antioch, in letters written early in the second century, used striking language about Jesus Christ and insisted on the reality of his flesh, suffering, and resurrection. Such statements show that the church’s confession was not merely that Jesus carried a divine message; it was that the one who suffered in history was the Lord who gives life. Yet individual patristic phrases must be read in their context and not treated as if every Father used later technical terminology with perfect consistency.

Historical theology benefits from distinguishing three questions: what a Father actually wrote; what that writing meant in its original controversy; and how later churches received or developed the idea. Selective quotation can misrepresent the past. Fathers sometimes disagreed, used terms differently, or made arguments that later theology refined. Their value lies in careful witness and debate, not in the assumption that every sentence is infallible.

From a Reformed standpoint, the Fathers are valuable servants but not masters of the conscience. They can demonstrate how early Christians read Scripture, expose modern claims that a doctrine arose without historical roots, and help identify the questions that required clarification. Nevertheless, every patristic claim must be tested by Scripture, which remains the final norm.

Study questions: What is the rule of faith? How did Irenaeus defend the unity of God’s saving work? Why must historical quotations be read in context?