Appendix A. Worked Examples
Example 1: HRM — Hybrid Work and Employee Engagement
Problem statement: An organisation has expanded hybrid working, but managers have limited evidence about how differences in autonomy, workload, digital access, and work–life boundaries relate to employee engagement across job groups. The issue matters because inconsistent access to flexible work may affect perceived fairness, retention, and wellbeing.
Aim: To examine the relationship between hybrid-work arrangements and employee engagement among staff in a defined organisation, considering autonomy, workload, and access to suitable digital resources.
Objectives: (1) Critically review research on hybrid work, engagement, autonomy, and work–life boundaries. (2) Describe staff-reported hybrid arrangements and engagement using a suitable questionnaire. (3) Examine associations between selected work conditions and engagement while accounting for relevant job characteristics. (4) Explore staff explanations for patterns that require contextual interpretation.
Approach: An explanatory sequential mixed-methods design may be appropriate if the survey is followed by interviews that explain important or unexpected patterns. The proposal must justify the sample, instrument, access, ethics, and integration plan. A cross-sectional design supports association claims, not definitive causal claims.
Example 2: Project Management — Handover Delays
Problem statement: Several projects have experienced delayed handovers, but existing records do not clearly distinguish the contribution of incomplete documentation, role ambiguity, approval bottlenecks, and supplier coordination.
Aim: To investigate factors associated with handover delays in a defined portfolio of projects.
Objectives: (1) Review literature on project handover, communication, and coordination. (2) Define and describe handover delay using consistent project-record indicators. (3) Examine associations between selected process factors and delay. (4) Explore stakeholder accounts of bottlenecks and develop evidence-linked recommendations.
Approach: A case-based design using project records and stakeholder interviews may be suitable. The researcher should define the case boundary and consider whether projects differ in complexity, budget, team structure, or procurement route.
Example 3: Education — Digital Access and Participation
Problem statement: Online learning participation differs among learners, while the institution has incomplete evidence about the role of connectivity, device access, platform usability, and competing work or caring responsibilities.
Aim: To examine how digital access and learner circumstances relate to participation in online learning within a defined programme.
Objectives: (1) Review evidence on digital inclusion and participation. (2) Describe access conditions and participation indicators. (3) Examine patterns across relevant learner groups, subject to privacy and adequate sample sizes. (4) Explore learner accounts of barriers and supports.
Approach: A mixed-methods design may combine a carefully designed survey with interviews. The study should avoid assuming that low participation indicates low motivation and should safeguard students from perceived pressure to participate.
Example 4: Logistics — Delivery Reliability
Problem statement: A distribution business reports variable delivery reliability, but the relative contribution of inventory availability, route disruption, supplier lead times, and order-processing practices is uncertain.
Aim: To assess factors associated with delivery reliability in a defined supply-chain setting.
Objectives: (1) Review relevant supply-chain and logistics literature. (2) Establish consistent indicators for delivery reliability and lead time. (3) Analyse available operational data to identify patterns. (4) Interview relevant staff or suppliers to interpret patterns and propose feasible improvements.
Approach: Quantitative analysis of operational records may be supplemented by interviews. Researchers should account for seasonal variation, changes in demand, incomplete records, and the possibility that efficiency measures shift costs or risks to other parties.