6. Literature Reviews, Evidence Gaps, and Conceptual Frameworks
6.1 The purpose of a literature review
A literature review establishes what is known, how it is known, where findings agree or conflict, which theories have been used, and what uncertainty remains. It should synthesise rather than simply summarise one article after another. The review needs a transparent search strategy appropriate to the project, including databases or repositories, keywords, dates, inclusion criteria, and reasons for excluding sources where relevant. Search completeness is always bounded by time, language, database coverage, and access.
6.2 Evaluating evidence
Evaluate authority, relevance, methods, sample, context, transparency, recency, and possible conflicts of interest. Peer review is useful but does not guarantee that a study is correct. A recent industry report may provide timely descriptive information but may not disclose its methods in enough detail for strong causal claims. A classic theory may be older yet remain foundational. The source should be judged against the claim being made rather than by publication date alone.
6.3 Identifying a genuine gap
A gap may be empirical (limited evidence in a population or setting), theoretical (competing explanations), methodological (weaknesses in prior designs), contextual (changed conditions), or practical (uncertainty about implementation). “No one has studied this” should not be claimed without a defensible search. A useful gap statement specifies what existing research does not yet explain and why that absence matters. A local replication may be valuable when context has changed or when earlier findings may not transfer.
6.4 Conceptual frameworks and variables
A conceptual framework maps the concepts central to a study and proposes how they may relate. In quantitative research, a framework may distinguish independent variables, dependent variables, controls, mediators, and moderators. In qualitative research, it may identify sensitising concepts while leaving room for participants’ accounts to challenge the initial framing. The framework should be justified by literature and should not be treated as proven merely because it appears in a diagram.
6.5 Socio-economic variables and contextual factors
Potential contextual variables include income band, education, employment status, contract type, work schedule, transport access, digital access, organisation size, location, and sector. Include a variable only when it has a conceptual reason and a feasible measurement strategy. Collecting excessive personal data creates privacy risks and analytic clutter. Researchers should also recognise that categories such as income and employment status can be sensitive, unevenly reported, and affected by local definitions.
6.6 Managing sources and avoiding plagiarism
Keep accurate notes separating direct quotations, paraphrases, and personal interpretation. Cite the original source for a claim whenever possible rather than relying on a chain of secondary citations. Use quotation marks for exact wording and include page or paragraph details when required by the chosen style. Paraphrasing means genuinely restating an idea in new language while preserving its meaning and citing its source; changing a few words is not adequate. Reference-management software can reduce clerical errors but does not verify the truth of a source.