Prof. Dr. Larry AdamsAcademic, Author & Researcher
Research in Business and Management · Chapter 7 of 23

Theory and the Conceptual Framework

❦

The Role of Theory

A theory explains why variables are related. A conceptual framework is a diagram and narrative that shows the variables of your study and the relationships you propose, grounded in theory and literature. A theoretical framework names the theory or theories that support those relationships.

Common Theories in Business and Management Research

TheorySourceTypical use
Technology Acceptance Model (TAM)Davis (1989)Technology adoption (perceived usefulness and ease of use)
Theory of Planned BehaviorAjzen (1991)Intentions and behaviour (attitude, subjective norm, perceived control)
UTAUTVenkatesh et al. (2003)Technology use
Technology-Organization-Environment (TOE) frameworkTornatzky and Fleischer (1990)Firm-level adoption
Resource-based viewBarney (1991)Competitive advantage and firm performance
Agency theoryJensen and Meckling (1976)Governance and ownership
Stakeholder theoryFreeman (1984)CSR and sustainability
Institutional theoryDiMaggio and Powell (1983)Isomorphism, legitimacy
SERVQUALParasuraman et al. (1988)Service quality
Job Demands-Resources modelBakker and Demerouti (2007)Burnout and engagement
Three-component model of commitmentMeyer and Allen (1991)Organizational commitment
Entrepreneurial orientationLumpkin and Dess (1996)Entrepreneurship and performance

Choose theories that fit your question, explain them briefly, and say how they inform each hypothesis.

Types of Variables

VariableRoleExample
Independent (predictor)The presumed causeWork-life balance
Dependent (outcome)The effectTurnover intention
MediatingExplains how or why the effect occursJob satisfaction
ModeratingChanges the strength or direction of the effectGender, firm size, experience
ControlHeld constant or statistically controlledAge, tenure

Building a Conceptual Framework: Steps

1. List the variables from your objectives.

2. Define each variable and its dimensions from the literature.

3. Use theory to decide the direction of relationships.

4. Draw the model, showing independent, mediating, moderating, and dependent variables and arrows for hypotheses.

5. Label each arrow with a hypothesis number.

6. Show control variables if used.

7. Write a narrative explaining the model.

A simple framework (text diagram):

Independent variable→Mediator→Dependent variable
Work-life balanceH1 →Job satisfactionH2 →Turnover intention
(Moderator: gender, H3, on the path from work-life balance to turnover intention)

Developing Hypotheses

For each relationship, argue from theory, then evidence, then context: (1) state the theoretical logic; (2) summarize the empirical support, including conflicting results; (3) predict the direction; (4) state the hypothesis. A mediation hypothesis states that X affects M, M affects Y, and the indirect effect is significant. A moderation hypothesis states that the strength of the X-Y relationship depends on W (an interaction effect).

Operationalization

Link each concept to a measurable indicator: use established scales (cite the source), adapt them with permission or acknowledgment, and avoid inventing new scales unless necessary. For qualitative research, the framework may be a sensitizing or emerging one, which you develop from the data (Gioia et al., 2013).

Common Mistakes

  • Drawing a model without theoretical justification.
  • Including too many variables for the sample size.
  • Confusing mediators and moderators.
  • Not aligning the model with the objectives and hypotheses.

CHAPTER 8