The Literature Review
❦
Why and What
The literature review shows what is known, what is debated, and where the gap lies. It also supplies the theory, the variable definitions, the measures, and the methods you will use (Booth et al., 2016; Ridley, 2012; Webster & Watson, 2002). It is not a list of summaries; it is an argument.
Searching
- Sources: Google Scholar; databases such as Scopus, Web of Science, Emerald, ScienceDirect, SpringerLink, SAGE, Taylor & Francis, JSTOR, EBSCO, and ProQuest; open-access repositories; and Sri Lanka Journals Online (SLJOL), which hosts many Sri Lankan journals (for example the Kelaniya Journal of Management and the Vidyodaya Journal of Management). Your library may provide access to many of these; ask a librarian.
- Search strings: combine key terms with AND, OR, and NOT; use quotation marks; try synonyms (for example "employee retention" OR "turnover intention").
- Citation chasing: follow the references of key papers (backward) and the papers that cite them (forward).
- Record your searches, and manage references with Zotero, Mendeley, or EndNote.
- Check quality: use peer-reviewed journals; consult journal rankings such as the Chartered ABS Academic Journal Guide or the ABDC list where relevant; be cautious about predatory journals (use the "Think. Check. Submit." checklist). Sri Lankan journals vary in indexing and quality ratings, so check each journal's indexing and review process (for example, the Kelaniya Journal of Management describes double-blind peer review and a quality rating in the JPPS system; Kelaniya Journal of Management, n.d.).
Types of Review
| Type | Use |
|---|---|
| Narrative review | Broad overview for most undergraduate work |
| Theoretical (conceptual) review | Compares theories and builds a framework |
| Empirical review | Summarizes and critiques findings and methods |
| Systematic review | Answers a focused question with explicit methods (Tranfield et al., 2003; Page et al., 2021) |
| Bibliometric review | Maps research with citation data (Donthu et al., 2021) |
Structuring the Chapter
A typical structure: introduction; theoretical review (the theories underlying your model); conceptual review (definitions and dimensions of each variable); empirical review (previous findings on each relationship, organized by hypothesis); Sri Lankan context (what has been found locally); research gap; and a summary that leads to the conceptual framework.
Reading and Writing Critically
For each source, record: the question, theory, context, sample, method, findings, and limitations. Use a synthesis matrix (sources in rows, themes in columns). In writing, organize by theme or argument, not by author, compare studies, explain disagreements, and use your own voice. Use a paragraph structure: a topic sentence, evidence from several sources, critical comment, and a link to your study.
| Weak writing | Stronger writing |
|---|---|
| "Perera (2019) studied X. Silva (2020) studied Y." | "Several studies report a positive effect of X on Y (Perera, 2019; Silva, 2020), but the evidence from small firms is mixed (Fernando, 2021), possibly because of..." |
(The authors named above are invented to illustrate style.)
Common Mistakes
- Copying abstracts or paraphrasing too closely (which leads to plagiarism).
- Relying on old, non-peer-reviewed, or low-quality sources.
- Not linking the review to the gap and the hypotheses.
- Quoting definitions without evaluating them.
- Failing to cite the original source of a theory (cite the original and a recent application).
CHAPTER 7