Chapter 20. University Standards, APA 7 and Research Integrity
20.1 There is no single universal university standard
Universities and programmes differ in dissertation templates, required chapters, word limits, reference styles, proposal milestones, ethics documentation, data retention, examiner rubrics, and requirements for publication or oral defence. The student must obtain the current official handbook and confirm requirements with the supervisor or doctoral office. A general textbook cannot override institutional policy.
20.2 Common doctoral quality expectations
- A clearly bounded problem with scholarly and practical significance.
- A critical and current literature review that establishes a defensible gap.
- A coherent theoretical or conceptual framework.
- Research questions and hypotheses aligned with the design.
- Ethics approval and transparent consent/data protection.
- Methods detailed enough to evaluate and, where possible, reproduce.
- Appropriate sample and measurement justification.
- Analysis matched to the design, assumptions and estimand.
- Accurate, complete reporting of estimates, uncertainty and null findings.
- Discussion that compares evidence with literature and recognises alternatives.
- Specific contribution, limitations and recommendations.
- Accurate citation, original writing, authorship transparency and accessible appendices.
20.3 Typical dissertation structure
| Section | Typical content | Important note |
|---|---|---|
| Front matter | Title page, declarations, abstract, acknowledgements, contents, lists | Use the university template and required order |
| Chapter 1 | Introduction, context, problem, aim, objectives, questions, significance, scope | Avoid presenting the full results in advance |
| Chapter 2 | Theory and critical literature review, gap, framework, hypotheses | Structure by argument and themes |
| Chapter 3 | Philosophy/logic if required, design, population, sampling, measures, procedures, analysis, ethics | Report what was planned and what was actually done |
| Chapter 4 | Results and analysis | Follow objectives and report estimates transparently |
| Chapter 5 | Discussion, implications, limitations, contribution, recommendations, conclusion | Some universities split these into separate chapters |
| Back matter | References, appendices, instruments, approvals, supplementary outputs | Protect confidential information |
20.4 APA 7 essentials
APA 7 uses author–date in-text citations and a reference list of works cited. Every in-text citation should correspond to a reference-list entry, and every reference-list entry should normally be cited in the text. Verify author spelling, publication year, title, journal/book details, volume, issue, page range or article number, and DOI/URL. Use sentence case for article and book titles where APA requires it, italicise journal title and volume, and present DOI links in URL format. Consult the official APA manual or university guide for edge cases.
Examples of in-text citation patterns: Narrative: Creswell and Creswell (2018) describe research design as a set of linked decisions. Parenthetical: Research design decisions should be aligned (Creswell & Creswell, 2018). Three or more authors: (Hair et al., 2019). Direct quotations require a page or other locator when available and should be used sparingly.
20.5 Referencing software and verification
Zotero, EndNote and Mendeley can help store sources and generate citations, but imported metadata are often imperfect. Verify the original source, correct author names and capitalization, remove duplicate records, and check the final formatted references. A reference manager does not guarantee APA compliance. Never cite a source that has not been read sufficiently to support the claim.
20.6 AI tools and academic integrity
If AI tools are used for brainstorming, editing, coding assistance or analysis support, follow the current university policy and disclose use when required. Verify every factual statement, calculation, code output and reference. Do not submit fabricated citations, upload confidential participant data to unapproved services, or represent AI-generated analysis as independently verified. Human authors remain responsible for the integrity and accuracy of the work.
20.7 Submission readiness
- Title, abstract, questions and conclusion describe the same study.
- All objectives are answered in the results and discussion.
- Every table and figure is numbered, cited in the text and explained.
- All reported statistics match saved output and analysis syntax.
- References are complete and consistently formatted.
- Appendices include permitted instruments, information sheets and supplementary material.
- Ethics approval identifiers and protocol deviations are reported where required.
- Confidential or identifying data are removed from the submission.
- Word count, margins, fonts, headings and declarations follow the official template.
- The final file has been proofread and checked against the examiner rubric.