Prof. Dr. Larry AdamsAcademic, Author & Researcher
How to Conduct Quantitative Research · Chapter 8 of 33

Part I — FOUNDATIONS AND RESEARCH PLANNING

Chapter 4. Theory, Literature Review and Research Gap

4.1 Purpose of the literature review

A literature review is a critical synthesis of knowledge, not a sequence of article summaries. It defines key concepts, identifies theoretical explanations, compares methods and findings, assesses the strength and limits of evidence, identifies contradictions, and demonstrates why the present study is needed. It should establish a traceable line from what is known to what the proposed study will add.

4.2 Search strategy

Develop a written search plan. Identify databases available through the university, such as Scopus, Web of Science, Business Source Complete, ABI/INFORM, PsycINFO, ERIC or discipline-specific indexes. Google Scholar can help discover literature but should not be treated as a transparent substitute for a systematic database search. Record search date, databases, search strings, date ranges, language limits, document types and screening criteria.

Example search string: ("perceived supervisor support" OR "supervisor support") AND ("work engagement" OR engagement) AND (employee* OR workforce). Adapt syntax for each database. Search the reference lists of important papers and use forward citation searching. For a systematic or scoping review, follow an explicit review protocol and relevant reporting guidance such as PRISMA where applicable.

4.3 Inclusion and exclusion criteria

Criteria should be decided before screening wherever possible. They might specify population, constructs, setting, design, date range, language, publication status and outcome. Do not exclude inconvenient findings merely because they conflict with the preferred hypothesis. Record reasons for excluding full-text articles if conducting a structured review.

4.4 Critical appraisal

For each study, assess the fit between question and design, sample and recruitment, measurement quality, missing data, statistical methods, effect sizes and uncertainty, confounding, generalisability, transparency and conflicts of interest. A statistically significant result from a weak design may provide less useful evidence than a precise, well-designed null result.

4.5 Evidence matrix

Author/yearContext/sampleDesign and measuresMain findingsStrengths/limitationsRelevance to current study
Study A (replace with verified citation)Industry, country, sampleSurvey; named validated scalesReport effect estimate and CISampling and measurement concernsSupports, challenges or contextualises model
Study B (replace with verified citation)Different populationLongitudinal or experimentalReport estimates and uncertaintyAttrition, external validityHelps explain design choice
Study C (replace with verified citation)Relevant settingAdministrative or survey dataReport consistency or contradictionConfounding and data limitationsShows the precise gap

4.6 How to synthesise

Organise the review around themes, constructs, mechanisms, methods or disagreements—not one paragraph per author. For each theme, state the pattern of evidence, explain where findings converge or diverge, identify plausible reasons (such as population, measure, timing or design), and explain the implication for the proposed model. Use both foundational sources and current high-quality empirical research. Recent does not automatically mean reliable, and older does not automatically mean irrelevant.

4.7 Research gaps

A gap may be theoretical (an explanation is underdeveloped), empirical (evidence is sparse or inconsistent), methodological (prior designs cannot resolve a question), contextual (evidence has not been tested in a relevant setting), measurement-related (constructs are measured poorly), or practical (evidence has not been translated into a decision). A geographic gap alone is not necessarily a meaningful contribution. Explain why the context could alter theory, measurement, boundary conditions or decisions.

4.8 Literature review chapter structure

  1. Introduction and scope of the chapter.
  2. Search and selection approach, if required by the review type.
  3. Definitions and conceptual boundaries of the main constructs.
  4. Relevant theories and the logic linking them to the study.
  5. Critical synthesis of empirical evidence by theme or hypothesis.
  6. Assessment of contradictions, methodological weaknesses and unresolved issues.
  7. Statement of the research gap and rationale.
  8. Chapter summary leading into the conceptual framework and hypotheses.