Prof. Dr. Larry AdamsAcademic, Author & Researcher
Qualitative Research · Chapter 19 of 26

Discussion, Limitations, Recommendations, Contribution to Knowledge, and Conclusion

❦

These sections are often written last, but should be planned before research begins, because they define what your study is for. Examiners read them closely.

Plan Backwards: The End-Point Note

At the proposal stage, write a one-page note answering:

QuestionWhy ask early
What gap will the study fill, and what might it add to theory and practice?Defines the contribution; checks the value of the topic
What kinds of findings might emerge, and how will I link them to the literature?Prepares the discussion
What limitations are likely (sample, access, language, my position), and how can I minimize them?Lets you reduce them where possible
Who could use my findings, and what could they do with them?Shapes recommendations
What further research might follow?Prepares the closing

Revise the note as the study develops.

The Discussion

Purpose: to interpret the findings in light of the literature and theory and to explain what they mean and why they matter. The discussion does not repeat the results.

Structure for each key finding or theme

1. State the key insight in one sentence.

2. Compare with the literature: confirm, extend, or contradict?

3. Explain using theory and the context (culture, sector, history).

4. Consider alternative explanations.

5. Link to the research question and the conceptual framework.

6. Show implications.

Elements to include

  • An integrated model or summary that brings the themes together.
  • Unexpected or contradictory findings, with honest explanations.
  • Theoretical interpretation: how do the findings support, refine, or challenge existing theories?
  • The role of context: what is specific to this setting?
  • Reflexive comments: how your position may have shaped interpretation.

Example: "The finding that confidence developed through experience and social support rather than through a prior belief in usefulness suggests that models emphasizing perceived usefulness may under-represent the social conditions of adoption among micro-entrepreneurs. This resonates with sensemaking perspectives, in which meaning is built through interaction (see Chapter 7), and with studies of small enterprises elsewhere that highlight peer influence."

Limitations

Purpose: to show an honest understanding of what the study can and cannot claim. Limitations are not a confession of failure; they guide readers and future research.

LimitationExampleHow to write it
Sample and transferabilityA small, purposive sample from one district"The findings are not intended to be statistically generalizable; their value lies in the depth of understanding, and readers should judge transferability to other contexts using the description provided."
Researcher subjectivityInterpretation shaped by my background"Reflexive journaling and peer debriefing were used to manage this influence, but it cannot be eliminated."
Self-report and recallAccounts may be incomplete or biased"Triangulation with documents was used where possible."
Language and translationInterviews in one language, analysis in another"Some nuance may have been lost; back-checking was used."
Access and contextLimited access to some groups; an unusual periodState what was not accessible
Time and resourcesA short fieldwork periodBe brief
MethodInterviews only; no observationSay what other methods could add
Analytic choicesOther analysts might generate different themesExplain this as a feature of interpretive analysis

Write limitations in a balanced tone, and turn each into a suggestion for future research. Avoid apologetic language, and avoid listing limitations that you could have avoided with more care. Do not use quantitative limitations (for example "the sample was too small for statistical power") for qualitative designs.

Recommendations

Purpose: practical and scholarly suggestions that follow from the findings.

TypeExamples
For practiceSpecific, feasible actions for managers, teachers, clinicians, or community organizations
For policySuggestions to regulators or government agencies, with reasons
For further researchQuantitative testing of themes; studies in other settings; longitudinal designs; studies with other groups; mixed methods
For theoryConcepts to refine or test

Make recommendations specific, justified by the evidence, and addressed to someone. Link each to a finding. Use a table:

FindingRecommendationWhoRationale
Adoption depended on trusted helpProvide local, accessible support for new usersPayment providers and local business associationsParticipants' confidence grew with accessible help

Avoid generic advice that does not follow from your data, and avoid language that implies certainty beyond the study.

Contribution to Knowledge

Purpose: to state what is new. It is expected in most master's and doctoral work, and increasingly in undergraduate honours work. Be precise and modest.

ContributionMeaningExample statement
TheoreticalExtends, refines, or challenges a theory; proposes a new concept or model"The study proposes a model of support-dependent trust in digital payment adoption."
EmpiricalNew evidence about a context, group, or process"It provides in-depth accounts from a group seldom studied."
MethodologicalA new or adapted way of collecting or analyzing data"It demonstrates the use of photo-elicitation with micro-entrepreneurs."
PracticalGuidance for practitioners"It offers insights for designing support for new users."
ContextualFills a gap in a geographic or sectoral context"It addresses a lack of qualitative research in regional districts."

State what the gap was, what you did, and what is now understood that was not understood before. Do not claim to be "the first" unless a systematic search supports it, and do not claim contributions the data cannot support.

The Conclusion

1. Restate the problem and aims briefly.

2. Summarize the main findings, answering each research question directly.

3. State the overall argument or "so what".

4. Note the implications concisely.

5. End with a closing message or reflection.

Do not introduce new data, repeat the discussion, or end with an apology.

Where These Sections Fit

Chapter (typical)Content
FindingsThemes with evidence
DiscussionInterpretation and theoretical contribution
ConclusionSummary, recommendations, limitations, and future research
Contribution to knowledgeIn the discussion or the conclusion, as the template requires

Abstracts

The abstract summarizes the problem, aims, method, main findings, and contribution in about 200 to 300 words; write it last.

CHAPTER 20