Rigor, Trustworthiness, and Quality in Qualitative Research
❦
Why Quality Is Judged Differently
Qualitative research is not judged by statistical reliability and validity, but by criteria suited to its aims and paradigm. Quality means the research is credible, coherent, transparent, ethical, and useful (Lincoln & Guba, 1985; Tracy, 2010; Yardley, 2000).
Lincoln and Guba's Criteria
| Criterion | Parallel in quantitative research | Meaning | Strategies |
|---|---|---|---|
| Credibility | Internal validity | The findings are believable and true to participants' views | Prolonged engagement, triangulation, member checking, peer debriefing, negative case analysis |
| Transferability | External validity | Findings may be applicable in other contexts | Thick description of context, participants, and setting; purposive sampling |
| Dependability | Reliability | The process is consistent and documented | Audit trail, detailed methods, code-recode, peer review |
| Confirmability | Objectivity | Findings are shaped by the data rather than researcher bias | Reflexivity, audit trail, quotations as evidence |
Nowell et al. (2017) show how to demonstrate trustworthiness in each phase of thematic analysis, and Shenton (2004) and Korstjens and Moser (2018) provide practical strategies.
Tracy's "Big-Tent" Criteria
Tracy (2010) offers eight criteria: (1) worthy topic; (2) rich rigor; (3) sincerity (self-reflexivity and transparency); (4) credibility (thick description, triangulation, member reflections); (5) resonance (the work affects readers); (6) significant contribution; (7) ethics; and (8) meaningful coherence.
Yardley's Principles
Yardley (2000) suggests four: sensitivity to context; commitment and rigour; transparency and coherence; and impact and importance.
Strategies for Rigor
| Strategy | How to apply |
|---|---|
| Reflexivity | Keep a reflexive journal; include a positionality statement |
| Triangulation | Multiple sources, methods, investigators, or theories |
| Member checking | Return summaries to participants for comment (with awareness of its limits: participants may not recognize analytic interpretations) |
| Peer debriefing | Discuss interpretations with colleagues or supervisors |
| Negative case analysis | Seek and explain disconfirming evidence |
| Thick description | Describe context in enough detail for readers to judge transferability |
| Audit trail | Keep dated records of decisions and analysis |
| Prolonged engagement | Spend enough time to understand the context |
| Saturation or information power | Show that the data are adequate |
| Rich quotations | Show how interpretations are grounded |
Reporting Standards
Reporting guidelines help readers to judge the work:
| Guideline | Notes |
|---|---|
| COREQ (Tong et al., 2007) | A 32-item checklist for interviews and focus groups, widely used in health research |
| SRQR (O'Brien et al., 2014) | A 21-item checklist applicable across qualitative designs |
| JARS-Qual (Levitt et al., 2018) | American Psychological Association reporting standards for qualitative research |
| Reflexive TA reporting guidelines and the Big Q Qualitative Reporting Guidelines | Braun and Clarke (2024) argue for a values-based approach and criticize checklists such as COREQ for risking methodological incongruence in reflexive work |
Use the checklist your university or target journal requires, and remember that a checklist is a drafting aid and not a measure of quality in itself (CASRAI, 2026; Braun & Clarke, 2024).
Generalization in Qualitative Research
Qualitative studies do not claim statistical generalization. They offer transferability (readers judge applicability), analytic or theoretical generalization (findings contribute to theory, as in case studies; Yin, 2018), and naturalistic generalization (readers recognize experiences; Stake, 1978). Smith (2018) discusses ways of presenting generalizability in qualitative work.
Common Mistakes
- Borrowing quantitative terms (validity, reliability, significance) without adaptation.
- Describing member checking as proof of truth.
- Listing strategies without showing how they were used.
- Claiming saturation without evidence.
CHAPTER 17