Focus Groups, Observation, Documents, Open-Ended Questionnaires, and Other Methods
❦
Focus Groups
A focus group is a facilitated discussion of a small group on a topic. It is useful for exploring shared views, norms, and how opinions develop in interaction (Krueger & Casey, 2015; Morgan, 1997).
- Composition: about 6 to 10 people, usually homogeneous on a key characteristic to encourage openness, and not previously acquainted where sensitive; avoid mixing people in power relationships.
- Number of groups: often three to six, until no new themes appear.
- Moderator and assistant: the moderator guides; the assistant records and observes.
- Guide: a short list of open questions (about five to eight), moving from general to specific.
- Ground rules: everyone may speak; no right or wrong answers; confidentiality (but note that confidentiality cannot be guaranteed in groups).
- Analysis: transcribe, note who said what, and analyze both the content and the interaction (agreement, disagreement, silence).
- Limits: dominant voices, conformity, and ethical issues of confidentiality.
Observation and Ethnography
- Roles (Gold, 1958): complete observer, observer as participant, participant as observer, and complete participant. Choose and declare your role.
- Preparation: define what to observe (setting, people, activities, interactions, time) and gain access.
- Field notes: record descriptive notes (what happened) and reflective notes (your thoughts and feelings) separately and promptly, using jottings in the field and full notes afterward (Emerson et al., 2011).
- Duration: ethnography needs prolonged engagement; short-term "focused" ethnography is used in applied research.
- Ethics: obtain consent for observation of people; consider covert observation only if justified and approved.
Document Analysis
Documents (policies, reports, minutes, annual reports, letters, websites, media) can be primary data or can support triangulation (Bowen, 2009). Consider authenticity, credibility, representativeness, and meaning; ask who produced the document, for whom, why, and in what context. Code them as you would transcripts.
Open-Ended Questionnaires and Qualitative Surveys
When interviews are not feasible, open-ended questionnaires can collect written accounts from many people. They give less depth than interviews, but can reach more participants. Design tips:
- Use a small number of open questions with clear prompts ("Please describe a time when..."), and allow space for longer answers.
- Add a few closed items for demographics only.
- Avoid leading wording; pilot the instrument.
- Analyze with thematic or content analysis.
- Use vignettes (short stories) or projective techniques (for example sentence completion) to explore sensitive topics.
- Note that this is often a "small q" design if you quantify the responses.
Visual, Digital, and Other Methods
- Photovoice and photo-elicitation: participants take or choose images and discuss them (Pink, 2013).
- Diaries and journals: capture experience over time.
- Netnography: study of online communities and posts, with attention to ethics, privacy, and consent (Kozinets, 2015).
- Social media and digital trace data: respect platform terms and ethics; consider anonymity.
- Qualitative longitudinal research: repeated interviews to study change.
- Delphi studies: structured rounds of expert opinions.
- Arts-based and participatory methods: drawing, mapping, drama, and storytelling.
Triangulation and Combining Methods
Using several methods or sources (for example interviews with observation and documents) helps to deepen understanding and strengthen credibility. Triangulation is not only about confirmation; contradictions are also informative. Plan how you will compare sources.
Common Mistakes
- Using focus groups to obtain individual experiences on sensitive topics.
- Taking field notes too late.
- Treating documents as neutral facts.
- Collecting too many types of data without a plan for analysis.
CHAPTER 12