Sampling, Participants, Access, and Saturation
❦
Purposive Sampling
Qualitative sampling aims to find information-rich cases that illuminate the questions, not to represent a population statistically (Patton, 2015). Common strategies:
| Strategy | Description | Use |
|---|---|---|
| Maximum variation | Cases that differ on key characteristics | Capture a range of experiences and common patterns |
| Homogeneous | Similar cases | Study a subgroup in depth (common in IPA) |
| Typical case | Average or representative cases | Show what is normal |
| Extreme or deviant case | Unusual successes or failures | Learn from the exceptional |
| Critical case | Cases that make a point dramatically | Test propositions |
| Snowball (chain) | Participants refer others | Hard-to-reach groups |
| Theoretical sampling | Sample guided by emerging categories | Grounded theory |
| Criterion sampling | All cases meeting criteria | Programme evaluation |
| Convenience | Easily accessible | Use with caution and justify |
How Many Participants?
There is no universal number. The appropriate size depends on the aim, the tradition, the diversity of the population, the depth of the data, and the analysis (Malterud et al., 2016; Hennink & Kaiser, 2022). Typical guides (not rules) are:
| Approach | Common range |
|---|---|
| Interpretative phenomenological analysis | About 3 to 10 participants; for student projects often 3 to 6 (Smith et al., 2009) |
| Phenomenology (other) | About 5 to 25 (Creswell & Poth, 2018) |
| Thematic analysis (interviews) | About 6 to 20 or more, depending on scope |
| Grounded theory | About 20 to 30, or until categories are saturated (Creswell & Poth, 2018) |
| Case study | One to five cases, with multiple data sources (Yin, 2018) |
| Focus groups | Several groups of about 6 to 10 participants; often 3 to 6 groups (Krueger & Casey, 2015) |
| Ethnography | A setting studied over an extended period |
Saturation and Information Power
- Saturation is the point at which new data add little new to the analysis. Code saturation (no new codes) is reached earlier than meaning saturation (full understanding of the issues), according to Hennink et al. (2017). Guest et al. (2006) found that in a fairly homogeneous sample most themes appeared within about 12 interviews.
- Information power suggests that the fewer participants are needed the more relevant the sample is to the aim, the more specific the sample, the stronger the theory used, the richer the dialogue, and the more focused the analysis (Malterud et al., 2016).
- Reflexive thematic analysis questions the concept of saturation as a fixed endpoint because meaning is generated by the researcher (Braun & Clarke, 2021). In your methodology, justify sample size with reference to your chosen approach and say how you judged adequacy.
Access and Recruitment
- Gatekeepers: obtain permission from organizations and community leaders in writing.
- Recruitment channels: letters, emails, posters, social media, professional associations, and referrals.
- Information sheet and consent form in the participants' language.
- Inclusion and exclusion criteria: for example "owner-managers with at least one year of experience".
- Vulnerable groups: additional protections and approvals.
- Incentives: decide what is appropriate and ethical (for example reimbursing travel or time).
- Records: keep a recruitment log of contacts, refusals, and reasons, and a participant table (pseudonym, key characteristics, date, duration, mode).
Describing the Sample
Provide a table of participants with pseudonyms and relevant characteristics, while protecting confidentiality (in small settings, avoid details that identify people).
Common Mistakes
- Claiming representativeness from a small sample.
- Choosing participants for convenience without a rationale.
- Not recording the recruitment process.
- Ending data collection without evidence of adequacy.
CHAPTER 10