Prof. Dr. Larry AdamsAcademic, Author & Researcher
DBA 704 — Week 2: Philosophical Foundations · 62 slides

Presentation · 62 slides

DBA 704 — Week 2: Philosophical Foundations

Doctor of Business Administration · Action Research module

Prof. Dr. Larry Adams

Week 2: Philosophical Foundations — part of the DBA 704 Action Research teaching module for doctoral students.

Free to view online and to download for teaching, with acknowledgement of the author. To reproduce or adapt any part of a deck, please request permission through the contact page beforehand.

  1. DBA 704 — Week 2: Philosophical Foundations

    DBA 704

    INTRODUCTION TO ACTION RESEARCH

    Philosophical Foundations of Action Research

    Ontology • Epistemology • Paradigms • Pragmatism • Interpretivism Participation • Positionality • Reflexivity • Theory ↔ Practice.

    Prof. Dr. Larry Adams

    Participant

    Researcher

    Knowledge

    01
  2. 1. Week 2 Learning Purpose

    • Move from: “I have identified an operational problem.”
    • Toward: “I understand the philosophical assumptions that influence how I will investigate that problem.”
    • Before deciding methods, researchers consider what you (they) believe about reality and how knowledge can be produced.
    • Key foundations: ontology, epistemology, ( and Axiology) research paradigms, researcher positionality and methodological assumptions.
    • Central message: methodology is connected to philosophy.
    02
  3. 2. Connect Week 2 to the Master Action Research Framework

    • Week 1 and 2 introduced: PROBLEM → DIAGNOSIS → PLANNING → ACTION → OBSERVATION/EVIDENCE → REFLECTION → LEARNING → REVISED ACTION.
    • Last week concentrated on identifying the PROBLEM.
    • This week asks what assumptions we bring to the problem and how those assumptions influence the way we understand and investigate it.
    • Add PHILOSOPHY above the framework.
    • Foundation: PROBLEM + PHILOSOPHY.
    03
  4. 3. Why Philosophy Matters in Action Research

    • Every researcher makes philosophical assumptions, whether explicitly acknowledged or not.
    • Example problem: “Why are employees resistant to a new organizational technology?”
    • One researcher may believe resistance can be objectively measured.
    • Another may see resistance as socially constructed through employee experiences.
    • A pragmatic Action Researcher may focus on understanding resistance while working with employees to improve implementation.
    • Different assumptions influence questions, evidence, participation, interpretation, methodology and conclusions.
    • Different views
    04
  5. 4. The Simple Research-Philosophy Sequence

    • PHILOSOPHY → What is reality?
    • EPISTEMOLOGY → How can we know about reality?
    • METHODOLOGY → What overall approach should we use to investigate it?
    • METHODS → What specific techniques will we use to collect and analyse evidence?
    • Keep these four levels distinct when writing doctoral research.
    • 1 • PHILOSOPHY
    • What is reality?
    • 2 • EPISTEMOLOGY
    • How can we know?
    • 3 • METHODOLOGY
    • Overall inquiry strategy
    • 4 • METHODS
    • Specific evidence techniques
    05
  6. 5. Example: From Reality to Methods

    • REALITY — What is happening with employee resistance?
    • KNOWLEDGE — How can we understand employees’ experiences?
    • METHODOLOGY — Action Research.
    • METHODS — Interviews, observations, documents, surveys, performance data, reflective journals, etc.
    • Important distinction: a method is not the same thing as a research philosophy.
    06
  7. 6. Ontology — What Is It?

    • Ontology concerns assumptions about the nature of reality.
    • Simple question: “What do we believe is actually real?”
    • In organizational research, a problem may have observable dimensions and experiential dimensions.
    • The researcher should make ontological assumptions explicit rather than leaving them hidden.
    • Reality
    07
  8. 7. Ontology in an Organizational Context

    • Operational problem: “Employee productivity is declining.”
    • Is declining productivity an objective reality?
    • Possible measurable indicators: output levels, production quantities, completion rates, error rates and processing times.
    • But ask: Does everyone experience the problem in the same way?
    • Management, employees, customers and IT staff may describe the same situation differently.
    08
  9. 8. One Situation — Multiple Perspectives

    • Management: “Employees are becoming less productive.”
    • Employees: “The new system is slowing us down.”
    • Customers: “The organization is providing poorer service.”
    • IT staff: “The system is functioning normally.”
    • All perspectives may contribute to understanding the operational situation.
    • The philosophical question is not simply “Who is right?” but also “How is the problem being understood?”
    • Management
    • Customers
    • Employees
    09
  10. 9. Objective and Subjective Dimensions of Organizational Reality

    • Observable dimensions: waiting times, costs, production volumes, error rates, turnover and delivery performance.
    • Experiential dimensions: perceptions, beliefs, attitudes, interpretations, relationships, organizational culture and employee experiences.
    • Action Research is often interested in how these dimensions interact.
    • The operational measure may show WHAT is happening; participant experience can help explain HOW and WHY it is experienced.
    10
  11. 10. Ontological Question

    • “Is the operational problem something that simply exists independently of people?”
    • Or: “Is its meaning partly shaped by how people experience and interpret it?”
    • There may not be one universal answer.
    • The student’s responsibility is to make the assumptions explicit and justify them.
    • The problem may have measurable features that can be observed.
    • The meaning of the problem may be shaped by people’s experiences and interpretations.
    11
  12. 11. Epistemology — How Do We Know?

    • Epistemology concerns how knowledge is produced and what we can reasonably claim to know.
    • Simple question: “How do we know what we know?”
    • This is particularly important in Action Research because knowledge may emerge through participation, action and reflection.
    • As a Student you should explain what counts as credible knowledge in your inquiry.
    • Knowledge
    12
  13. 12. Knowledge in Action Research

    • Knowledge can be generated through experience and participation.
    • It can also emerge through dialogue, observation, action, intervention, reflection, interpretation and organizational learning.
    • Knowledge does not necessarily come only from an external researcher observing participants.
    • Participants may possess important knowledge about routines, processes, informal practices, customer experiences, workflow problems and organizational history.
    13
  14. 13. Participants as Knowledge Producers

    • Traditional research can sometimes position participants primarily as subjects from whom data are collected.
    • Action Research can position participants as participants, collaborators and co-inquirers.
    • This does not mean every Action Research study gives all participants equal decision-making power.
    • It means recognizing that people experiencing an operational problem may possess valuable knowledge about it.
    • Researcher
    • Participant
    • Co-inquirer
    14
  15. 14. Example: Inventory Management

    • Problem: persistent inventory discrepancies.
    • Management believes: “Employees are not following procedures.”
    • Warehouse employees identify outdated records, malfunctioning scanners, frequently changed product locations and urgent orders that bypass normal procedures.
    • The researcher’s understanding of the problem changes.
    • Lesson: knowledge can emerge through participation and inquiry.
    15
  16. 15. Research Paradigms — The Big Picture

    • You as a Student do not need to memorize philosophical terminology.
    • You need to understand how different paradigms influence research assumptions.
    • When you Introduce: positivism, post-positivism, interpretivism, pragmatism and critical approaches.
    • Focus on: What assumptions does the paradigm make, and how does that affect the research?
    16
  17. Pragmatic and Pragmatism

    • A Pragmatic person or approach solves problems in a sensible, realistic way based on actual conditions rather than fixed theories or abstract rules
    • Pragmatism
    • Practical approach: The habit or policy of dealing with issues using practical, real-world solutions.
    • Philosophical tradition: A late 19th-century American movement started by thinkers like Charles Sanders Peirce, William James, and John Dewey.
    • Core belief: Views an idea or a "truth" as valid only if it works and has useful, successful practical consequences.
    • Example: Using trial and error to see what fixes a broken community program rather than following an old ideological rulebook
    17
  18. 16. Positivism

    • Generally emphasizes observable phenomena, measurement, objective evidence and relationships between variables.
    • Example question: “Does employee training reduce production errors?”
    • Evidence may include number of errors before training and after training.
    • The focus is heavily on measurable evidence and systematic testing.
    • What can be observed?
    • What changed?
    • What does the evidence support?
    18
  19. 17. Post-Positivism

    • Recognizes that complete objectivity may be difficult.
    • Still emphasizes systematic inquiry, evidence, empirical investigation, attempts to minimize bias and critical testing of explanations.
    • Useful when You as a student ask: “Can research ever be completely objective?”
    • Key message: researchers can seek objectivity and rigor without assuming perfect objectivity is always achievable.
    19
  20. 18. Interpretivism

    • Emphasizes how people understand and interpret their experiences.
    • Instead of only asking: “How many employees resisted the new technology?”
    • An interpretive researcher may ask: “How do employees understand and experience the introduction of the new technology?”
    • May explore meanings, experiences, perceptions, organizational culture and social interactions.
    • Experience
    20
  21. 19. Pragmatism

    • Pragmatism is concerned with knowledge, action and consequences, with particular attention to what helps us understand and address practical problems.
    • Ask: What approach will help us understand this problem?
    • Ask: What can we do about it?
    • Ask: What happens when we act?
    • This creates a useful philosophical connection with Action Research.
    21
  22. 20. Why Pragmatism Can Fit Action Research

    • Action Research is concerned with practical problems, action, consequences, learning, change, participation and context.
    • These emphases can be compatible with pragmatic thinking.
    • Warning: do not write only “I chose pragmatism because I want to solve a problem.”
    • Doctoral justification must explain assumptions about reality, how knowledge is generated, why those assumptions fit the problem and why Action Research follows logically.
    22
  23. 21. Critical Perspectives

    • Critical approaches may focus on power, inequality, organizational structures, control, marginalization and whose interests are served.
    • Example: management may describe a performance system as an efficiency improvement, while employees experience it as increased surveillance.
    • Critical question: Who benefits from the intervention, who bears the costs and whose voice is being ignored?
    • This can be valuable in Action Research.
    • Who makes decisions?
    • Who gains?
    • Who is missing?
    23
  24. 22. Comparing the Paradigms

    • Your task is not to select the paradigm that sounds most impressive. Justify the paradigm that best fits your problem and assumptions.
    24
  25. 23. Action Research and Pragmatism

    • Action Research repeatedly asks: What is happening? Why is it happening? What can we change? What happened when we changed it? What did we learn? What should we do next?
    • This emphasis on action, consequences and learning creates a natural connection with pragmatic approaches.
    • But Action Research is not reducible to pragmatism.
    • You as a Student must distinguish a methodology from a philosophical orientation.
    25
  26. Positionality

    • Factors of Positionality
    • Your positionality is built from the social and political groups you belong to. Common factors include:
    • Race and ethnicity
    • Gender and sexuality
    • Social class and income
    • Ability status
    • Geographical location
    26
  27. 24. Philosophy Does NOT Mean “Which Method Will I Use?”

    • Error: “I will use interviews, therefore I am interpretivist.”
    • Error: “I will use a survey, therefore I am positivist.”
    • Methods do not automatically determine philosophy.
    • The same interview can be used within different philosophical and methodological approaches.
    • The important issue is how evidence will be understood and what claims will be made from it.
    • Interview
    • ≠
    • Not automatically determined
    27
  28. 25. Methodology versus Methods

    • METHODOLOGY = the overall logic and strategy of inquiry.
    • Examples: Action Research, case study, ethnography, grounded theory, experimental research.
    • METHODS = specific techniques for generating evidence.
    • Examples: interviews, surveys, observations, documents, focus groups and performance data.
    • Key statement: ACTION RESEARCH IS A METHODOLOGY.
    • The overall inquiry strategy ACTION RESEARCH
    • The evidence techniques Interviews • Surveys • Observation • Documents
    28
  29. 26. Action Research Can Use Different Types of Evidence

    • Qualitative evidence: interviews, observations, reflective journals, focus groups, documents and participant narratives.
    • Quantitative evidence: performance measures, operational metrics, survey responses, error rates, processing times and productivity indicators.
    • Mixed evidence: combining qualitative and quantitative evidence where appropriate.
    • Key question: Why are these forms of evidence appropriate for the research question and Action Research cycle?
    29
  30. 27. Researcher Positionality

    • Ask: “Who am I in relation to my research problem?”
    • A DBA student may be a senior manager, department manager, consultant, employee, executive, external researcher or organizational partner.
    • This position can influence access, relationships, participant behaviour, power, intervention and interpretation.
    • Positionality is therefore a methodological issue, not a personal footnote.
    • Researcher
    30
  31. 28. Why Positionality Matters

    • Example: A manager researches “Why are employees not adopting the new organizational system?”
    • Employees may be reluctant to criticize the system because the researcher is their manager.
    • The researcher’s position may influence participant behaviour and therefore the evidence generated.
    • Students must identify these influences and explain how they will manage them.
    31
  32. 29. Reflexivity

    • Reflexivity is the researcher’s critical examination of how their position, assumptions, experiences and actions influence the research process.
    • It is more than saying: “I tried to be objective.”
    • Ask: What assumptions did I bring? How did my position affect participants? Did my expectations influence interpretation?
    • Also ask: Did managerial authority influence participation? Did I overlook alternative explanations? How did my actions change the research setting?
    • Researcher
    32
  33. 30. Insider Research — Advantages

    • Organizational access
    • Contextual knowledge
    • Established relationships
    • Understanding of organizational processes
    • Ability to implement change
    • Important point: insider status can provide valuable contextual understanding.
    • Insider
    33
  34. 31. Insider Research — Risks

    • Role conflict
    • Bias and assumptions
    • Power relationships
    • Confidentiality problems
    • Political pressures
    • Conflicts of interest
    • Key message: insider status is neither automatically an advantage nor a disadvantage; it is a methodological condition that must be managed and critically examined.
    34
  35. 32. Philosophy and the Action Researcher

    • Detached researcher: “I observe what is happening.”
    • Interpretive researcher: “I seek to understand how participants interpret what is happening.”
    • Pragmatic Action Researcher: “I work with participants to understand the problem, take action, evaluate consequences and learn.”
    • Critical Action Researcher: “I investigate how power and organizational structures shape the problem and work with participants toward meaningful change.”
    • Observe
    • Understand
    • Act
    • Challenge
    35
  36. 33. Knowledge Through Action and Reflection

    • One of the most important concepts of Week 2.
    • Action is not simply the final step after research; action itself can generate knowledge.
    • Example assumption: “Employees need additional training.”
    • Training is introduced, but employees still struggle.
    • Reflection reveals that the deeper problem is contradictory instructions from different departments.
    • Lesson: knowledge can be generated through action and reflection.
    36
  37. 34. Theory ↔ Practice

    • Action Research creates an opportunity for interaction between scholarly literature and organizational experience.
    • Theory informs practice: literature helps understand explanations and possible interventions.
    • Practice informs theory: organizational experience can reveal unexpected findings, contextual conditions, limitations, new relationships and new questions.
    • This interaction can become a potential doctoral contribution.
    • Literature Concepts Explanations
    • ↕
    • Action Experience Learning
    37
  38. 35. The Double Purpose of Action Research

    • PRACTICAL PURPOSE → Improve the organizational situation.
    • RESEARCH PURPOSE → Generate knowledge and understanding through the improvement process.
    • Students should keep both purposes visible.
    • A project that only improves the organization risks becoming consultancy.
    • A project that only studies the organization without meaningful action may no longer reflect the central logic of Action Research.
    • Improve the organizational situation
    • Generate knowledge through the improvement process
    38
  39. 36. The Week 2 Doctoral Question

    • If Action Research is designed to change an organization, how can the researcher know whether the knowledge produced through that change is credible?
    • This question prepares students for later work on:
    • Week 3 — Action Research cycles
    • Week 5 — collaborative design
    • Week 6 — evaluation
    • Week 7 — reflection
    • CREDIBLE KNOWLEDGE?
    • Researcher
    39
  40. 37. Week 2 Case Study — Digital Transformation

    • A large service organization introduces a new digital platform.
    • Six months later: employee adoption is low; customer complaints have increased.
    • Management believes employees are resistant.
    • Employees claim the system is difficult to use.
    • IT staff believe the technology is functioning correctly.
    • Senior management wants immediate improvement.
    • A DBA researcher inside the organization is asked to investigate.
    40
  41. 38. Case Study — Ten Questions for Discussion

    • 1. What is the reality of the problem?
    • 2. Is “employee resistance” an objective fact or an interpretation?
    • 3. What different perspectives exist?
    • 4. What counts as knowledge about the problem?
    • 5. Should employees be subjects or participants?
    • 6. How might the researcher’s managerial position influence findings?
    • 7. Would an interpretive approach be useful?
    • 8. Would a pragmatic approach be useful?
    • 9. Could Action Research be appropriate?
    • 10. What ethical and positionality issues might arise?
    41
  42. 39. Class Exercise — Same Problem, Different Philosophies

    • INTERPRETIVIST What would you ask?
    • Use the same problem: “Employees are not adopting the new digital system.”
    • GROUP A — Positivist: What would you measure?
    • GROUP B — Interpretivist: What would you ask employees?
    • GROUP C — Pragmatist: What could you change and test?
    • GROUP D — Critical: Who has power and whose interests are being served?
    • Bring the groups together and compare what each perspective reveals.
    • POSITIVIST What would you measure?
    • A
    • B
    • PRAGMATIST What could you change?
    • CRITICAL Who has power?
    • C
    • D
    42
  43. 40. What Is the Best Paradigm?

    • There is no universal answer that one paradigm is always superior.
    • The appropriate philosophical position depends on the research problem.
    • It also depends on the research purpose, assumptions and intended contribution.
    • Doctoral-level reasoning means explaining WHY the chosen perspective fits the inquiry.
    • ↓
    • ↓
    43
  44. 41. Student Activity — Philosophical Positioning

    • Identify your own operational problem.
    • ONTOLOGY — What do I believe about the nature of this problem?
    • EPISTEMOLOGY — How can I develop credible knowledge about this problem?
    • PARTICIPANTS — Whose knowledge and experience are important?
    • RESEARCHER — What is my position in relation to the problem?
    • PARADIGM — Which philosophical perspective best fits my inquiry?
    • JUSTIFICATION — Why is this philosophical position appropriate?
    • METHODOLOGY — Why might Action Research be appropriate?
    44
  45. 42. Student Worksheet — Fill in the Boxes

    • My operational problem: ______________________________
    • What I believe is real about the problem: ______________
    • How I can know about the problem: _____________________
    • Whose knowledge is important: _________________________
    • My relationship to the organization: ____________________
    • My preliminary paradigm: ______________________________
    • Why that paradigm fits: _______________________________
    • Why Action Research may fit: ___________________________
    • What is real?
    • How do I know?
    • Who am I?
    • What perspective?
    45
  46. 43. Philosophical Position Statement — Template

    • “My research assumes that ____________________. I understand knowledge about the operational problem as ____________________. Knowledge will therefore be generated through ____________________. Participants will contribute knowledge by ____________________. My position as a researcher/practitioner may influence the research through ____________________. An Action Research methodology is appropriate because ____________________.”
    • Tell students: this is only a preliminary statement.
    • They will refine it later as their understanding develops.
    • Draft → Refine
    46
  47. 44. What a Weak Response Looks Like

    • Weak response: “My research uses pragmatism because my research is practical and I want to solve a problem.”
    • Why is it insufficient?
    • It does not explain ontology.
    • It does not explain epistemology or knowledge production.
    • It does not explain the researcher’s role or participants.
    • It does not show the methodological connection.
    47
  48. 45. What a Stronger Response Looks Like

    • A stronger response connects the research problem, philosophical assumptions, evidence, participants, action and reflection.
    • It explains why the chosen orientation fits the problem rather than simply naming a paradigm.
    • It shows how knowledge will be developed through operational evidence, stakeholder engagement and reflection on intervention.
    • It explains why Action Research follows logically from the philosophical position.
    48
  49. 46. Important Warning for Students

    • Do not choose a research philosophy simply because another doctoral student used it.
    • Do not choose a philosophy because your supervisor said it is the “best” philosophy.
    • Start with the research problem and purpose.
    • Identify your assumptions about reality and knowledge.
    • Then justify the philosophical position that logically supports your inquiry.
    • Justify
    49
  50. 47. Common Student Errors — 1 to 4

    • ERROR 1: “I am using interviews, therefore I am interpretivist.” → Methods do not automatically determine philosophy.
    • ERROR 2: “My research is practical, therefore I am pragmatic.” → Explain the philosophical reasoning.
    • ERROR 3: “Action Research is qualitative.” → Action Research is a methodology and can potentially use different forms of evidence.
    • ERROR 4: “Participants provide data.” → In collaborative Action Research, participants can contribute knowledge and participate in inquiry and action.
    50
  51. 48. Common Student Errors — 5 to 7

    • ERROR 5: “Because I work in the organization, I know the problem.” → Insider knowledge is valuable but must be critically examined.
    • ERROR 6: “I am objective because I am the researcher.” → Consider positionality, influence and reflexivity.
    • ERROR 7: “Philosophy is only theoretical.” → Philosophical assumptions influence research questions, methodology, evidence and interpretation.
    51
  52. 49. Week 2 Connection to Assessment 1

    • Assessment 1 asks students to identify an operational challenge and explain how foundational principles of Action Research apply to addressing it.
    • Week 2 strengthens that work by asking:
    • What is the operational problem?
    • What assumptions do I have about that problem?
    • How can knowledge about the problem be generated?
    • Who should contribute knowledge?
    • What is my role as researcher?
    • Why does Action Research fit these assumptions?
    52
  53. 50. Week 2 Reading Strategy

    • Do not simply collect quotations or definitions.
    • Ask: What does this author argue?
    • What assumptions underpin the argument?
    • What are the strengths and limitations?
    • How does the argument apply to my operational problem?
    • How does the literature justify my methodological choice?
    • Move from: READING → SUMMARIZING to READING → ANALYZING → EVALUATING → APPLYING.
    • →
    • →
    53
  54. 51. Week 2 Homework / Deliverable

    • PRELIMINARY PHILOSOPHICAL POSITION STATEMENT
    • Recommended length for a formal weekly activity: approximately 500–750 words, adjustable to module requirements.
    • Include: 1) operational problem, 2) ontological assumptions, 3) epistemological assumptions, 4) research paradigm, 5) participants, 6) researcher positionality, 7) why Action Research is consistent with the philosophical position, and 8) scholarly support.
    • The statement is preliminary and should develop as the research develops.
    • Problem + Ontology + Epistemology + Paradigm + Participants + Positionality + Action Research + Literature
    54
  55. 52. Week 2 Doctoral Reflection

    • Complete: “Before this week, I assumed that my operational problem was ____________________.”
    • Then: “After considering ontology, epistemology and different research paradigms, I now understand that ____________________.”
    • Final reflection: “What assumptions might I have been making about the problem without realizing it?”
    • This is a valuable way to begin developing reflexive doctoral thinking.
    55
  56. 53. Week 2 Closing Activity — Return to the Master Framework

    • Display: PROBLEM → DIAGNOSIS → PLANNING → ACTION → OBSERVATION/EVIDENCE → REFLECTION → LEARNING → REVISED ACTION.
    • Place PHILOSOPHY above the entire framework.
    • Explain: philosophical position influences how you understand the problem, engage participants, identify credible evidence, interpret findings and justify the Action Research methodology.
    56
  57. 54. Week 2 Conceptual Map

    • DBA 704 ACTION RESEARCH
    • ↓
    • OPERATIONAL PROBLEM
    • ↓ What is reality? — ONTOLOGY
    • ↓ How do we know? — EPISTEMOLOGY
    • ↓ RESEARCH PARADIGM — Positivism / Post-positivism / Interpretivism / Pragmatism / Critical
    • ↓ METHODOLOGY — ACTION RESEARCH
    • ↓ PARTICIPANTS + RESEARCHER ROLE + POSITIONALITY
    • ↓ DIAGNOSIS → PLANNING → ACTION → EVIDENCE → REFLECTION → LEARNING → REVISED ACTION → NEXT CYCLE
    57
  58. 55. Six Key Messages for Students

    • 1. Every researcher makes philosophical assumptions, whether explicit or not.
    • 2. Ontology asks what reality is; epistemology asks how we can know about it.
    • 3. Research philosophy should logically connect to the research problem and purpose.
    • 4. Action Research recognizes that participants can contribute important knowledge about organizational problems.
    • 5. The practitioner’s position can influence research, making reflexivity and transparency important.
    • 6. Action Research connects theory and practice through action, evidence, reflection and learning.
    58
  59. 56. The Key Transition from Week 1 to Week 2

    • END OF WEEK 1: “I have an operational problem.”
    • END OF WEEK 2: “I have an operational problem, but I now recognize that the way I understand that problem depends partly on my assumptions about reality, knowledge, participants and my own role as a researcher.”
    • That is a major step toward doctoral thinking.
    • WHAT IS MY PROBLEM?
    • ↓
    • HOW DO I UNDERSTAND REALITY AND KNOWLEDGE?
    59
  60. 57. Preparing Students for Week 3

    • We now know what our problem is.
    • We have begun to consider the philosophical assumptions underlying our inquiry.
    • Next question: How do we actually conduct Action Research in practice?
    • WEEK 3 — ACTION RESEARCH CYCLES: DIAGNOSIS → PLANNING → ACTION → OBSERVATION/EVIDENCE → REFLECTION → LEARNING → REVISED ACTION.
    • Bridge: Week 1 = problem; Week 2 = philosophy; Week 3 = the Action Research cycle.
    • Problem
    • Philosophy
    • →
    • Cycle
    • →
    60
  61. 58. Final Takeaway — Think Like an Action Researcher

    • Do not ask only: “What should we do?”
    • Ask: What is happening? Why is it happening? What assumptions am I making? Whose knowledge matters? What can we change? What evidence will show what happened? What have we learned? What should happen next?
    • The philosophical foundation helps the researcher justify how these questions are approached.
    • The objective is not merely to fix a problem, but to produce credible knowledge through action, participation, evidence, reflection and learning.
    • Reflect
    • Act
    • Think
    61
  62. 59. DBA 704 Week 2 — The Complete Picture

    • Why Action Research? How does the methodology follow from the problem, purpose and philosophical assumptions?
    • Who am I? How might my role influence the inquiry? How will I practise reflexivity?
    • What is reality? How is knowledge produced? Who is a legitimate knowledge producer?
    • THEORY ↔ PRACTICE
    • PARTICIPATION + CREDIBLE EVIDENCE + REFLEXIVITY
    62
01 / 62

Slides in this deck

  1. DBA 704 — Week 2: Philosophical Foundations
  2. 1. Week 2 Learning Purpose
  3. 2. Connect Week 2 to the Master Action Research Framework
  4. 3. Why Philosophy Matters in Action Research
  5. 4. The Simple Research-Philosophy Sequence
  6. 5. Example: From Reality to Methods
  7. 6. Ontology — What Is It?
  8. 7. Ontology in an Organizational Context
  9. 8. One Situation — Multiple Perspectives
  10. 9. Objective and Subjective Dimensions of Organizational Reality
  11. 10. Ontological Question
  12. 11. Epistemology — How Do We Know?
  13. 12. Knowledge in Action Research
  14. 13. Participants as Knowledge Producers
  15. 14. Example: Inventory Management
  16. 15. Research Paradigms — The Big Picture
  17. Pragmatic and Pragmatism
  18. 16. Positivism
  19. 17. Post-Positivism
  20. 18. Interpretivism
  21. 19. Pragmatism
  22. 20. Why Pragmatism Can Fit Action Research
  23. 21. Critical Perspectives
  24. 22. Comparing the Paradigms
  25. 23. Action Research and Pragmatism
  26. Positionality
  27. 24. Philosophy Does NOT Mean “Which Method Will I Use?”
  28. 25. Methodology versus Methods
  29. 26. Action Research Can Use Different Types of Evidence
  30. 27. Researcher Positionality
  31. 28. Why Positionality Matters
  32. 29. Reflexivity
  33. 30. Insider Research — Advantages
  34. 31. Insider Research — Risks
  35. 32. Philosophy and the Action Researcher
  36. 33. Knowledge Through Action and Reflection
  37. 34. Theory ↔ Practice
  38. 35. The Double Purpose of Action Research
  39. 36. The Week 2 Doctoral Question
  40. 37. Week 2 Case Study — Digital Transformation
  41. 38. Case Study — Ten Questions for Discussion
  42. 39. Class Exercise — Same Problem, Different Philosophies
  43. 40. What Is the Best Paradigm?
  44. 41. Student Activity — Philosophical Positioning
  45. 42. Student Worksheet — Fill in the Boxes
  46. 43. Philosophical Position Statement — Template
  47. 44. What a Weak Response Looks Like
  48. 45. What a Stronger Response Looks Like
  49. 46. Important Warning for Students
  50. 47. Common Student Errors — 1 to 4
  51. 48. Common Student Errors — 5 to 7
  52. 49. Week 2 Connection to Assessment 1
  53. 50. Week 2 Reading Strategy
  54. 51. Week 2 Homework / Deliverable
  55. 52. Week 2 Doctoral Reflection
  56. 53. Week 2 Closing Activity — Return to the Master Framework
  57. 54. Week 2 Conceptual Map
  58. 55. Six Key Messages for Students
  59. 56. The Key Transition from Week 1 to Week 2
  60. 57. Preparing Students for Week 3
  61. 58. Final Takeaway — Think Like an Action Researcher
  62. 59. DBA 704 Week 2 — The Complete Picture