19. Editing, Proofreading and Academic Style
Revision at three levels
Structural revision asks whether the argument answers the question and sections appear in a logical order. Paragraph revision asks whether each paragraph makes a clear contribution and is supported. Sentence editing addresses grammar, concision, terminology and tone. Proofreading checks typographical errors, punctuation, numbering, formatting and references.
Common weaknesses
Frequent problems include a vague purpose, an overly broad literature review, unsupported generalisations, long paragraphs, inconsistent terminology, unexplained acronyms, excessive quotations, abrupt transitions and conclusions that go beyond the data. A practical response is to identify the three most consequential problems first rather than trying to fix everything simultaneously.
Academic concision
Remove repeated points, redundant phrases and unnecessary signposting. Replace 'It is important to note that the results clearly demonstrate' with 'The results show'. However, do not remove methodological details needed for reproducibility or nuance needed for accurate interpretation.
Proofreading methods
Proofread a printed or differently displayed copy when possible. Read slowly, search for common error patterns, check one type of issue at a time and verify citations separately. Reading aloud can reveal awkward syntax. Automated grammar tools can identify possible issues but may misinterpret technical language, dialect and intended meaning.
Final quality assurance
Check the assignment question, word limit, headings, page numbers, tables, figures, appendices, citations, reference list, ethics statements and file naming. Confirm that every in-text citation has a matching reference and every listed reference is cited where the style requires this. Reopen the final file after saving to ensure that formatting has not shifted.