7. Literature Reviews and Theoretical Frameworks
What a literature review does
A literature review maps, evaluates and synthesises what is known about a research problem. It establishes concepts, identifies patterns and disagreements, evaluates methods, clarifies gaps and justifies the current study. It is not a sequence of one-paragraph summaries of individual authors.
Narrative, systematic, scoping and integrative reviews
A narrative review offers a reasoned synthesis and may use a flexible search process. A systematic review uses explicit, reproducible methods for searching, screening and synthesising studies. A scoping review maps the breadth and characteristics of evidence, while an integrative review may combine diverse forms of literature. The review type should fit the question and be reported transparently.
Synthesis matrix
Build a matrix with columns for author/year, context, theory, research question, design, sample, measures or data, findings, limitations and relevance to the current study. Compare studies across themes rather than writing one isolated summary per source. The matrix helps identify recurring findings, methodological differences and genuine gaps.
Research gaps
A defensible gap may be empirical (limited evidence in a population), contextual (findings may not transfer to a setting), theoretical (an explanation is incomplete), methodological (a design has not addressed a question), conceptual (constructs are inconsistently defined) or practical (evidence does not resolve a decision). A gap should matter. 'No study has ever examined this exact combination' is not enough unless the combination has a clear scholarly or practical rationale.
Theory and conceptual frameworks
A theoretical framework applies an established theory to explain a problem. A conceptual framework organises concepts and proposed relationships for the study; it may draw on one or several theories. Define each construct, justify each proposed link and distinguish theory-driven hypotheses from exploratory questions. A diagram is not a substitute for explanation.
Model synthesis paragraph
Across the studies reviewed, leadership support is frequently associated with technology adoption, but the strength of the relationship varies by organisational size and implementation context. Several studies rely on self-reported cross-sectional measures, limiting causal interpretation. This study therefore examines leadership support alongside employee capability and perceived usefulness, while treating adoption as a context-dependent process rather than a single universal outcome.