4. Critical Thinking, Argument and Evidence
Claims, reasons and warrants
An argument contains a claim, reasons supporting it, evidence for those reasons and an explanation of why the evidence supports the claim. The often-implicit connection between evidence and conclusion is called a warrant. Academic writers should make this reasoning visible, especially when readers may not share the writer's assumptions.
Evaluating evidence
Ask whether the source is relevant, credible, current enough for the topic, methodologically sound and appropriately interpreted. A peer-reviewed article is not automatically correct; a government report may be authoritative for official statistics but not necessarily for every causal explanation. Check sample, measures, context, funding or conflicts, limitations and whether the conclusion exceeds the evidence.
Counterarguments and limitations
A strong argument acknowledges plausible alternatives. Explain what competing explanations exist, what evidence favours one interpretation and what uncertainty remains. A limitation is not a confession of failure; it is a boundary around the claims the study can responsibly make. Avoid dismissing alternatives without examining them.
Causal reasoning
Association does not by itself establish causation. Causal claims require a defensible design and consideration of alternative explanations, temporal order and plausible mechanisms. Cross-sectional survey data may identify relationships but often cannot establish that one variable caused another. Use 'associated with' or 'predicts statistically' where appropriate, rather than 'causes'.
Critical questions
For every major source, ask: What is the central claim? What evidence supports it? How were data generated? What assumptions are made? What is omitted? Which population or context does it concern? Do other studies agree? What would weaken this interpretation? These questions turn reading into analysis.